TBH I think Wrath was declining before DF even released, and that’s coming from a Wrath diehard, who has recently opened their eyes and changed perspective. I don’t think DF success is what is causing the decline, and tbh I think it might be too soon to say DF is a success. It’s only been a week. Give if a few months and see how it’s doing. I think what killed Wrath was the expansion itself, and Blizzard’s poor management of servers and poor player communication.
I think a lot of people were super excited and hyped for Wrath, but once the expansion dropped, you got to 80 and now have a character that is as fair progressed as it can be right now, there’s nothing to do except either level an alt, or raid log. I rolled ON CLASSIC VANILLA exclusively hoping they’d one day release Wrath. I was so pumped with the Wrath announcement, and the hype leading up to launch. The first few weeks were amazing. I had a blast with my first character and even my alt. But, like Vanilla and TBC; there just isn’t enough to do, at least in comparison to retail.
In fact, I’d argue there was more to do in vanilla and tbc then there is in Wrath:
Vanilla, you always needed gold and consumes, so you spent HOURS farming. That’s likely what you were doing at max level in between raids. If not farming, you were probably pvping, as the pvp scene was pretty active. Also let’s not forget how long it actually took you to level. It took at least a month just to hit 60, and that’s if you were treating it like a full time job. Obviously, you’d get there much quicker if you were buying dungeon boosts, but most people couldn’t afford to do that until at last mid-late BWL… unless of course, they were gaining gold through illegal methods.
TBC introduced arena, badges and rep. There were dungeons and raids that required attunements, getting enough badges from heroics to buy gear took a large chunk of your time too because heroics were not something you could finish in 10 mins. Rep took you weeks to complete because of how long heroics took, and the PVP scene was still active, buts was starting to see a decline. If you weren’t doing those things, you were likely farming gold, farming rep for non-major reputation factions or working on professions.
However on Wrath, there’s nothing to really work towards. Once you’re at max level; you’re done with the badge grind in a few weeks, and that would cover your main spec and off spec. You can go from friendly-exalted with a major faction in less than 2 days if you do a full world tour. You could be done rep grinding the major reps in a week, maybe 2 tops? Heroics are a cakewalk, they take 10-15 mins to complete so even grinding for badges you’re locked out in 4 hours. Between the long queue time for arena on most servers, the amount of bots that are queued in BG’s, Wintergrasp being a lagfest that’s pretty much unplayable for a huge chunk of the playerbase, and not even needing to control WG for VoA, the PVP scene is in shambles and an absolute JOKE. Even the raiding scene sucks right now. Not just that the raids are getting stale and no one needs anything anymore, but the ‘buffed’ content that was given to us only gave the bosses additional HP… which means nothing when the game’s been solved for 15 years. You’re just following the same mechanics for an additional 2-3 mins per boss. A surplus of gold is easier to get than it ever has been, and let’s not forget, RDF is a beloved feature that many want to see in game. Without it, many don’t want to bother leveling an alt. So what’s left? You raid log, which is what most are doing now… if they even bother to log in each week to raid at all. OH and let’s not forget the Server locked BS that split up guilds and friend groups.
I was a ride or die Wrath player, but between how little there actually is to spend my time on, how Blizzard has maintained the servers and communicated with the player base, all the changes that were made that impacted the average player significantly, and and how poor of a state the game is currently in… DF didn’t kill Wrath. Wrath killed Wrath… and don’t start with “We all knew Phase 1 was gonna be a faceroll,” while that’s true; even once we get into phase 2, there’s still nothing new. Heroic+ is simply meant to be a catchup mechanic, so it means nothing to you if you don’t NEED to catch up.
TLDR: Nothing to work towards makes for a boring game. Everything in Wrath can be completed in a few weeks, than all there is left to do is raid log. Servers are either mega or dead, with no RDF/Cross-server queue to compensate. Blizzard failed us with how poorly the managed the servers, and game upkeep.