We didn’t come back to TBC because all the changes made in Retail were good. We came back because we liked it when the game took more effort and didn’t hand you everything on a silver platter.
You might have enjoyed Wrath more, and you’ll get your chance to play Wrath with all of Wrath’s ‘improvements’ when Wrath comes out.
Check the sheer numbers of threads, combined with the two polls that were 80/20 in favor of dual spec. It is a large large majority that are not satisfied with respecs in it’s current state.
We all have an opinion as to when “retail” began. Some consider BC retail, others not until WoD. I think you’ll find the vast majority consider the trilogy part of the “classic” game and everything after as retail. It’s ok to hold a distinct minority view, I often do, but one should know when they hold a minority view.
I don’t understand what you mean here. There’s a fine line between bringing back the complete classic experience and bringing back a classic game and changing a few things for a modern era. Duel spec was a fantastic addition to the game without any drawbacks. There isn’t any argument to not have it other then “It wasn’t in TBC, I don’t like it.”
It allows players to engage with the game in a more enjoyable manner and that’s what counts at the end of the day. Farming primals as a healer blows, no matter how much people might not want to admit it. Spending 100g to respec for arena feels terrible, and also directly relates to higher BG Q times.
That may be true. Yet at the same time I suspect most people would consider wrath not retail and that was your statement I was addressing. People are frequently inconsistent.
Maybe. I have no claim to how I would suspect anything that represents “most.”
Wrath certainly isn’t/wasn’t TBC. If that’s a different statement from a claim then maybe I would care to dispute it, but at this point, I’m actually leaning towards TBC being Retail in that it certainly has more Retail features than Vanilla did, and the discussions around adding more are definitely happening, though they seem to be fruitless.