Omg thank you. I’ve been thinking this for months, and every time I see the other tank deliberate for a bit and then just pick hog because I picked Orisa, I just think “ugh…”
And sure enough, we always lose point A on defense and then either one of us switches or we just lose point B relatively quickly too.
Orisa hog had a time and a place, but Orisa is nowhere near main tank material enough to do anything relevant.
Sigma hog, however…
What’s funny is that Sigma is viable in virtually every situation where Orisa used to be good.
Socrates:
How many topics about this do you need?
Seriously, this is like the 50th post about this from you alone
I don’t recall making 50 posts about not playing Hogrisa.
2 Likes
Sombra tracer was very effective against Orisa and Sigma, but nobody would run it…
That being said, the entire Dive 2.0 comp required significantly more effort to play successfully than Orisa Sigma comps.
Sigma Hog is still not a great comp. Sigma doesn’t have enough barrier to play with Hog, although it’s not nearly as bad as Orisa Hog. The only tank who has enough barrier to play with Hog is Reinhardt, and even then, it’s almost always inferior to Rein Zarya unless you’re countering Wrecking Ball with it.
Well, it is a bit concerning that OpenQueue isn’t an option for the main competitive mode, because of GOATs and TripleBarrierGOATs.
And if they aren’t going to do something like 1-3-2.
Then that means some pretty substantial changes to 2-2-2 Tank popularity is needed.
1 Like
50 threads about the state of tanks in some form
I find Roadhog is a hero with no place in the game. Without mitigation, he is never a hero you want on your team. Sure, his damage is good, but so is Dva’s… and Zarya’s… and Sigma’s. And they have more to bring to the team.
Sure, he can get picks. Against bad teams that play with weak or no barriers. But in serious games with good picks on the other team, he’s just bad. He kind of feels like the DPS Moira of tanks, only good if everyone else in the game is bad.
The gas cloud mechanism isn’t gr…
Yeah, no kidding.
It’s pretty much a miracle round in gold to get a team wtih:
A competent Winston.
A competent Dva.
A competant Genji.
A competent Lucio.
A competent second healer (I think it was Moira?)
I mean, I have basic pattern recognition.
Orisa used to win most games and now she almost univerally loses.
Thus, balance matters.
I feel like the ruinous nerfs to Mei make it really difficult to counter a Reinhardt if your tanks cannot do it.
Let’s not fix any of the problems the game actually has or anything. No, let’s just give a ludicrous buff to Genji who IS FINE, buff Hanzo in completely the wrong way, and ruin Moira for no reason.
I guess the Echo change is ok.
and you should be able to. frankly, any 2 tank combos should work together well in this game. the design mentality of “off tank” and “main shield tank” is trash and needs reworked entirely.
any combo of 2 tanks should bring enough to the table to be effective, same thing i believe with supports. they should all heal equally well, in different ways, that way it removes the idea of stacking the strongest healers in an attempt to cheese. it removes the concept of “we literally can’t win this matc…
I feel like we’re overdue for major balance fixes.
Come on, fix tanks already! Are you waiting for every non Reinhardt tank to quit or something?
Buff Baptiste. I think in his entire lifespan as a playable hero there were maybe two months where I didn’t feel actively bad picking him for a team. Just raise some numbers, but by less than last time.
And maybe tune up some of the worse DPS, like Junkrat and Symmetra.
The state of tanks is basically ruining the game for me. You have Reinhardt, you win, if you, you lose. It’s not fun.
Maybe we need to start completely over, just remove all tanks except for Rein Zarya, and re-introduce them carefully, completely rebalanced, in a state the community will accept to be comparable in power with Rein. Redesign the whole role, one at a time. Make sure people will accept the new tanks so the game designers don’t just trashcan them all as they have now.
I don’t know,…
That’s like, an entire category.
And they haven’t fixed the problem yet, so I’m still going to talk about it. I get several forced losses a day by brainless tank comps.
4 Likes
Then expect to get flagged as spam
I do and the mods restore the posts because it isn’t spam .
3 Likes
It is spam because you spam the same topics that have the same message of “Rein is too good, other tank comps are terrible”
Unfortunately 1-3-2 is garbage, and many players still struggle against multiple tanks.
I wish there were a way to make multiple tank comps equally viable and with clear combos countering other combos.
Unfortunately it seems that one combo will be labeled as “best” and run ad nauseum without consideration for anything else.
I mean, you’re not really wrong but at least it’s better than Hog/Ball. Also, I don’t really care for blaming the community for playing something that should by all rights be perfectly viable.
This is Blizzard’s screw up. If nothing else, the more people that play it, lose, and complain about it, the more likely they are to actually fix things.
That is quite certainly false flagging.
That is voicing your opinion, That is what the forums are for.
He is not doing anything wrong. I do not care if you disagree or agree with him, He is doing nothing wrong.
1 Like
True, but for Platinum and below and most of Quickplay, that doesn’t need to apply.
1 Like
But that isn’t what I’m saying here.
I’m saying, don’t play Orisa with Hog.
Orisa can be played with Rein and Sigma.
Hog can be played with Rein and nothing else.
Even if Rein was nerfed into the absolute bottom of F tier “Don’t play Orisa with Hog” would still be true. You’d want some kind of Sigma comp then, or dive.
2 Likes
Hmm…
What if I start spamming threats about how glorious MonkeyBall is and how Dive 2.0 is an underrated comp?
It would be a mission to counteract all the Rein Zarya stuff
That’s because of anti-dive heroes like McCree, Moira, Brigitte, etc. not because of Orisa/Sigma. Either nerf the anti-flankers or buff the flankers.
Honestly Winston is desperately overdue for buffs, he’s the worst tank statistically even lower than Orisa.
No it isn’t
And yet when people made threads about Moira they were flagged. Sounds like classic forums bias to me.
I mean, Orisa Sigma isn’t that bad, it’s a hell of a lot better than Orisa Hog. I think Orisa Rein is better, but Orisa Sigma has a lot going for it.