The comments saying it scaled 1:1 are from years after vanilla ended, the first one seems to pop up in 2010…During Cata. That is years for a bug to happen so it’s not proof that the sword actually scaled 1:1 during vanilla itself, if there are comments from 2006 that say it does then post it.
Would be great if this change would get some kind of mention in the patch notes - I guess both scaling and snapshotting were bugs given this fix, but does that mean they ADDED scaling between 1.12 and 3.x when it was (possibly) confirmed scaling? Do we have to farm this if there’s a TBC Classic? So many questions…
Most likely removing the scaling is a change to the game. Blizz has made it clear that their no changes stance is pretty narrow, as they frequently break things they don’t like.
They are more concerned with the spirit of the game rather than creating a 1:1 mechanical and addon copy of vanilla.
Basically, even if it was in vanilla, abusing it could cause it to be changed under the current developers.
I wanted to take a second and clear up any misconceptions about the nature of this bug fix. The Runeblade of Baron Rivendare neither scaled with +healing nor snapshotted any +healing effects in Original WoW or the 1.12 Reference client. This behavior was a bug that was introduced into WoW Classic. As such, the fix that went into 1.13.3 that removed the +healing benefit and snapshotting restored this item to it’s original 1.12 state.
As this bug is now resolved we will be closing this thread now. As always, thank you for your reports and analysis!