Blizzard, Your art style is perfect! Don't change it

General Discussion
76

I agree completely. It pains me to see people saying, unironically “its not too late to redo the entire art style, you can still fix this”… The reforged look is incredible. I’m blown away and I really hope they stick with it. I can understand some nitpicky feedback, like the riflemen being too large, or a piece of armor out of place, whatever.
But what they’ve managed to do (and if you look at the concept art for reforged this becomes clear) is create an entirely unique look that is different from WoW or Warcraft 3 or HotS WITHOUT departing from that iconic “warcraft style”. That’s exactly what was needed for this, and I’m personally beyond excited to see the rest of the game.
I hope the development team isn’t intimated or bullied out of the new look they’ve created. The buildings, the heroes, the environments (even though early) all look amazing.
It’s a tough job because you really can’t please everyone. But they’re doing good work. I haven’t been this excited for any gaming news in a long long time.

5 Likes
77

lol Are you on crack?

1 Like
78

No, I just don’t watch anime

79

Please explain to me how on earth this is LESS cartoony than reforged.

https://i.ytimg.com/vi/oC6Ea7glhPo/maxresdefault.jpg

1 Like
80

I love the art style, too! So excited to play!

1 Like
81

Had to login to voice my opinion, I am an artist working in the industry. Art of reforged is fantastic. Everyone imagined what would it be like if in-game graphics were as good as cinematics. Keep up the good work Blizz, cant wait to get my hands AGAIN on best game ever made!

5 Likes
82

I like the art style but it looks like the hero glow is gone :frowning:

1 Like
83

Speak for yourself, please, I didn’t. I always understood that unlike cinematics, in-game graphics ain’t supposed to reflect the world and events in it ‘realistically’. Just like those symmetrical melee maps ain’t supposed to show the ‘real’ geography of the warcraft world.
Well, reforged art style is still cartoony, anyway, even more than the original game, just in a different way.

1 Like
84

Unfortunately, I’m liking it less each time I see it. Maybe for those of us that prefer the old style, we could have a user project to just up-rez and up-poly the old models (smooth the curves, shape the faces, etc) and interpolate their animations for a higher frame rate.

There’s just way too much going on in the new models. Footman shields used to be plain color with a dot, very easy to see. Now there’s a ton of fancy pattern on them. Orc towers are covered in high-contrast bone spikes which are less clear.

Actually, I do prefer the raiders, though. The big fluffy tails help clarity.

85

Agreed. Those who prefer the Disney cartoon style can stick with the original game.

86

A lot of the particle effects haven’t been redone yet (I think even ranged unit missiles were the old ones in stuff we’ve seen so far), so it wouldn’t surprise me if the hero glow hasn’t been set up yet either.

The interesting part is that we’re seeing hero units without them, so I wonder if for mapmaking’s sake they’re divorcing hero models from the hero glows but still adding them in the end. Just not baking them into the models.

87

You meant to say can stick with reforged? Cause it’s reforged what looks like a disney cartoon, a bit mixed with anime and marvel movie style. Old WC3 is more like hand-drawn comic book style.

2 Likes
88

The devs have explicitly stated that the original is too cartoon-like, and that they went with a more realistic approach because Warcraft is not a cartoon (probably hinting at Overwatch).

1 Like
89

Crazy world we’re living in, if people think overwatch isn’t cartoony. lol.

3 Likes
90

I wasn’t clear enough. Imo, Overwatch is the definition of a cartoon, and Blizzard are familiar with it enough that they feel weird with WC3 being in any way similar to it.

1 Like
91

I wish that blizzard adds cloud shades which are passing by through the map.

Imagine the worker which chopps wood and the cloud passes by above him. What a harmonic moment.:relieved:

2 Likes
92

what about wind and trees, smoke, fire, dust moving in its direction ?

3 Likes
93

There would be no need to go out anymore :relieved:

1 Like
94

this is definitely the aim :smiley:

1 Like
95

Despite the information that Blizzard outsourced the art to that company Lemon Sky, I think they did a great job with the models. It strikes a nice balance of WC3 and what WC2 would look like in HD.

5 Likes