The TLDR: OP is insulting the communication team but doesn’t even look at the posts he’s linking. He’s just creating drama.
For context and my opinion on Matchmaking
So right there are some issues with the matchmaker, anyone that thinks it's perfect is deluded.
Personally, I found matchmaking a lot better in season 3 with roles being matched and I can see it.
I have seen bad games and one sided stomps but more often due to tilt than matchmaker.
Regardless, I'm happy with the system right now.
Now I want to get on to your point. Most of those posts aren’t objective and since you put time into I’ll try and break them down.
Reading the posts
Post 1 - 2 death on defense and enemy get's completion on attack on Rein... is bad. Then 1 death on attack while getting a ton of kills without winning... there not hard committing. It's easy to tell their gaslighting the DPS and using their support rank and scoreboard to cope. So it's not a far leap to they would gaslight the Matchmaker.
Post 2 - “The matchmaking IS rigged” if people believe in that they can’t really be objective or be expected not to try there best to win games which does mess up matchmaking
Post 3 - Legit, post guy has GM MMR and is not a GM player and the rank system tells him he’s diamond. They are addressing this but his problem isn’t the matchmaker here.
Post 4 - Legit, confused that ranks don’t match your MMR but his problem isn’t the matchmaker here.
Post 5- Not really complaining about matchmaking but lack of info on the people you are playing. Pretty objective take.
Post 6- “In s4”- they are talking about OW1
Post 7- Likly again another person confused that rank != MMR
Post 8- Winstreak after change in matchmaker… Not indicating a problem really as this could be because it was fix but still this is direct feedback about the matchmaker.
Post 9- Not very clear but could be feedback
Post 10- If true. Legit issue. He doesn’t really explain though or give details.
Post 11-THIS IS NOT FEEDBACK BUT A LINK TO SOMETHING (this kinda reflects badly on you OP that you don’t really care about the topic but want to create controversy)
Post 12- Wild claims with no evidence. There is no feedback here.
Post 13- Asking Dev to be fired. This is just toxic
Post 14- Guy explains his issue and he’s confused. He blames matchmaking but his reasoning is extremely flawed "de-motivating if you are always the support with the most heal ". Support isn’t about healing.
Post 15- This is probably the first good piece of feedback. It explains the issue, and they understand how matchmaking works and should work. THIS IS THE STUFF DEVS NEED AND SHOULD LISTEN TO.
Post 16- While basic this is good feedback to.
Post 17- Not really feedback
Post 18- Nercoing a post… speaking for all ranks… this is venting not feedback.
Post 19-Minor feedback
Post 20- “I’m just going to make a forum post everyday the matchmaking is rigged” not feedback
Post 21- Expects to get free win for buying skins - It’s a joke not feedback.
Post 22- THIS IS NOT FEEDBACK BUT A LINK TO SOMETHING
Post 23- Basic feedback
Post 24- is post 23
Post 25- Not really feedback but is talking about an issue with it so sure I’d say it is.
Post 26- Legit, but again is about rank != MMR
Post 27- Same as post 1
Right summary time.
8 out of the 27(25) posts are actual feedback and I’m counting the posts that are just it’s feeling worse after the update kind of posts.
There are almost as many that are about not understanding rank != MMR (which is a point they’ve talked about and heard the bad feedback) and but more are posts that just aren’t feedback.
You are linking vent posts, trolling posts, posts that don’t have anything to do with matchmaking and even posts that are just links to dev posts and claiming that it’s feedback and it’s proof the commuication team isn’t doing there job.
The fact is it isn’t and it shows either you don’t understand the issue or you’re gaslighting the commuication team.
My opinion on this… if you are going to insult the communication team with accusations about passing people’s feedback on and you’re not even reading the posts all you are doing to creating drama and being a hypocrit.
If you do care about the issue, you’re doing more damage than good imagine if Devs read this post and thought “Oh great someone compiled people’s feedback for us!” then read about some guy gaslighting his team then some other guy going on about how he deserves free win cause he paid for a skin. They’ll instantly ignore it question the value of reading such posts in the future.
At least you’ve highlighted why feedback doesn’t get back to them because of posts like this and those you’ve highlighted out of the 25, only 1 I’d consider was detailed well thought feedback yet it got only got 2 likes on it, for someone that took their time and put in their experience and what they think is happening in context to what has been said about the matchmaker.
Some guy spamming every day that matchmaking is rigged, 18 likes.
So guess what, the community communicates via likes for people to make trolling spam posts, rather than actual detailed feedback posts.
In that context, the fact they pick up anything is amazing, and imo reflects there doing a better job than you imply.
Either way, I get it you’re annoyed they said they only get positive feedback but to lie and gaslight people’s jobs is kinda sucky bro.