Echo from Overwatch: Nay or Yay?

If youā€™re referencing Wall-E, it goes deeper than that. Having female robots resemble an iPod and having male robots resemble likeā€¦ blocky piles of garbage is a fairly ingrained trope. I would be more bothered by Echoā€™s design if Orisa didnā€™t exist for contrast.

She becomes an enemy hero, which is a significant difference. Instead of having a safe pick to turn into, it encourages more case-by-case ult usage to grab whoever is best within range.

5 Likes

Or they could go the Mei route and mix things up and make it a trait?

But yeah, she has to wait. I have been waiting for The Overmind, Selendis, and Tosh for ages

He is the troll that posts only pure negative things, just ignore him.

He just doesnā€™t care about anything he doesnā€™t like. Even he created fake accounts to report a comment that hurted him :rofl::rofl::rofl:

Donā€™t worry, I wonā€™t mention what hurt you again, Vulture :face_with_hand_over_mouth:

3 Likes

Iā€™m Yay to any character.

3 Likes

blizzard already made it clear that they donā€™t want to allow cloning enemy heroes in HotS. this was decided years ago when they were still balancing ultimate evolution.

You see what I told you? Vulture again speaking baseless ravings :rofl:

Yeah, and? It is not necessary to completely copy a heroā€™s kit, there may be changes. An example of this is Dva, who has in OW her E as an Ultimate.

The fact of not giving to her, her original ultimate, does not prevent or complicate her being added to the game as your ignorance declares:

Good heavens, donā€™t complicate things yourself Vulture :grimacing:

5 Likes

Honestly we can just give her something else or make her copy other things. Imagine if you can copy mercs, bosses, and structures. That would be pretty cool.

Also even if you keep it I do not see an issue. Abathur can only copy his team, but Echo can copy the enemy.

5 Likes

That character simply would not be viable in hots, it would end up being the most op of all at launch.

yea, she look like a cool mage.

Iā€™d like to see a citation, because Iā€™d love to read those reasons. If it was in regards to Abathur, the reason may have more to do with Abaā€™s mechanics over some grand rule. Basically, UE is +1 body with no consequences, and having free reign on nine targets might have made him to too versatile. Echo trades one body for another, so is presence neutral, and can only turn into an enemy target in range. That makes it a lot more limited.

There certainly are reasons to have some rules in place. Theyā€™ve explained many times why things like mass rez and mana drain do not work in this game. However, if they find a reasonable way to implement it, they should absolutely go nuts. Cool ideas always trump old rules. Team 5 announced they would never add a new class to Hearthstone back in KotFT, and, wellā€¦

2 Likes

Maybe make it an E abillity where she can copy her allies and AA only, using her own abilities will break the illusion.

Or like Sylas, she can copy a basic ability instead of their ult. It could be coded to be random or last used ability.

I like this too. What if she can copy the enemy (Hero and username) in order to confuse them whoā€™s who. She can use their abilities but they deal no damage or no heal.

2 Likes

I like this idea, she can be like the Spy from TF2.

Actumally its pronounced EEEEEEE-V

Pretty much this.
And it turns out sheā€™s actually in Overwatch. I guess their creative team really got sacked or something and replaced with 2nd year students.

1 Like

They tried this in starcraft 2 - a unit that could copy an enemy unit. And it ended up in the enemy not using units that were too dangerous to copy, just because the concept of copying was in the game. DB was designer in sc2 back then, he clearly learned the lessons in HOTS.

By translation, it would basically happen the same way here. You wonā€™t be blocking counters to your own comp by picking the counters as part of your comp. A hero that could copy another hero would be a 100% ban rate. For all eternity.

Why would anyone want a female OW hero that has no clothes. Such a low blow to the rule 34 community.

I wouldnā€™t mind Echo around here. The potential cloning got me thinking though, since I donā€™t think Iā€™ve seen it in any match: can Abathur clone the Vikings or Chogall?

Nay. There are a bunch of other heroes who should come before her.

Going off my own memory I think so, but itā€™ll only clone the actual target. I.e., no gall AI and only the individual viking.

Ah yes, the replicant.

2 Likes

You say that like this game is Rock, Paper, Scissors. Turning into one hero for ~twenty seconds every ~two minutes is not going to break the game. Itā€™s not that simple.

In an RTS, there really are units that are straight-up hard counters, as well as units that are just better than others in every way. This is a MOBA, where every hero is designed to be equally as powerful and useful. If this was an issue for HotS, it would also be an issue for Overwatch (which it isnā€™t).

The OP isnā€™t saying right away. Theyā€™re just asking if you want them at some point ever.

1 Like

Yeah, but ā€œsome pointā€ can be so long as to essentially be never between the release frequency and enormous lineup of heroes.

Iā€™d rather not see Echo in the foreseeable future if it means other OW heroes need to wait longer to get released