Yet another guild bank post

[Jomjom-bloodscalp (Jomjom)]

Even Blizzard acknowledged in the panel that the argument “Just don’t use it” is not valid, as the things become part of the fabric of the game.

Indeed. I can agree.

I’m still asking for it though.

[Shimy-khadgar]

Guild banks are purely for convenience and should not be added for the same reason dual specialization shouldn’t be added for convenience sake. If you want to play two specs without respecing every time then you level another character of the same class. If you want a guild bank you coordinate with the leadership and decide who will hold what or if one person holds everything.

I fail to see how guild banks are more secure than a guild bank alt… guild banks open up the possibility and create an avenue for the guild master to basically take everyone to the cleaners. At least with guild bank alts you can have multiple people holding different things to alleviate the stress of “losing it all” if someone dies IRL/decides to screw everyone over/ isn’t online all the time to access the character.

[Manzo-argent-dawn (Manzo)]

@Eloraell-moon-guard

The point being that you made a specific statement without evidence, to support your claim that Guild Banks are needed. That statement has no support from any Blizzard post about Guild Banks, from their game guide description to the announce description, describing that they were created for the security aspects.

And it’s been the security aspects alone I’m interested in. I don’t care if they’re a byproduct of TBC or Cataclysm or whatever.

I don’t care about extra storage, I don’t care about gold reserves. All the convenience is immaterial. I’m only interested in the security.

And it’s necessary.

@Shimy-khadgar

So what happens if a guild master decides he hates his guild so he gkicks everyone

Would be the same response as in Retail. Guild master is the ultimate master here.

Guild Bank Theft

Goodbye to any credibility that guy had, or will ever have. Moreso in Classic than anywhere else.

What even the Guildmaster cannot do, is legally access an account that is not his. He can’t “get his stuff back” if he put someone else in charge of the guild bank alt.

[Starman-zangarmarsh (Starman)]

Who stole the item? How much help will those precious logs provide?

Well if someone took some devilaur leather there damn well better be something made from it for that person or he gets reprimanded.

But you know that.

[Shimy-khadgar]

So you are saying that punishment for said action would be purely in the hands of the servers community??

[Jomjom-bloodscalp (Jomjom)]

should not be added for the same reason dual specialization

I think dual spec would have a larger impact than gbanks by far. The game needs the gold sink. That IMO is a part of the atmosphere that’s needed.

I also think that gbanks can be a gold sink as well.

[Shimy-khadgar]

Why do you think the game needs a gold sink??? Most people are going to be poor as dirt lmao

Yea I need another gold sink outside of 100g a pop flasks

[Starman-zangarmarsh (Starman)]

If you don’t then too many people control the economy.

[Shimy-khadgar]

People and guilds will control the economy regardless of a one off gold sink

[Manzo-argent-dawn (Manzo)]

So you are saying that punishment for said action would be purely in the hands of the servers community??

If a Guildmaster does it? Yes. Blizzard required ten different people to vouch for the guild at its creation. The Guildmaster is arbiter, and the community can have at him.

What happens if you have a good guildmaster, but the owner of the guild bank alt drops off the planet? What happens to your guild bank and everything in it?

[Jomjom-bloodscalp (Jomjom)]

why do you think the game needs a gold sink???

A few years down the road, we will need something to sink gold into.

If you don’t want to pay for the Gbank. Then you don’t have to.
It should be costly and out of reach of anyone less than 60.
Just like spells, professions, and riding; its gonna cost, you won’t be able to buy it all right away.

[Shimy-khadgar]

The game should not be altered to fascilitate mass storage because the people playing the game decided they want to stockpile things. You get the bank space you get, if you want more you can make a new character.

[Shimy-khadgar]

You can have gbanks a year after naxx

50,000g, increasing by 50,000 per tab.

[Manzo-argent-dawn (Manzo)]

The game should not be altered to fascilitate mass storage because the people playing the game decided they want to stockpile things. You get the bank space you get, if you want more you can make a new character.

I am posting from my bank alt.

What happens to my guild’s guild bank alt if the owner does drop off? No one has said anything about that.

[Jomjom-bloodscalp (Jomjom)]

The game should not be altered to fascilitate mass storage because the people playing the game decided they want to stockpile things.

i reply with

It should be costly and out of reach of anyone less than 60.
Just like spells, professions, and riding; its gonna cost, you won’t be able to buy it all right away.

and the storage space doesn’t need to be huge either.

You get the bank space you get, if you want more you can make a new character.

This is true.

You can have gbanks a year after naxx

50,000g, increasing by 50,000 per tab.

Thank you! But, its not for you to decide.

[Fesz-cenarius]

Maybe it’s because I am searching for my own posts, but I searched for posts written by me including the terms loot trading, AV 1.12, sharding and even right click report.

Then it should be easy for you to post a link or two.

I checked the “AV 1.12 will destroy classic” thread and you’re curiously not in it. I would think for sure you’d be defending classic at all costs.

Was that thread created AFTER Blizzard made their decision that they would be implementing 1.12 AV?

If it was, there is your answer. I already indicated that when they made their decidion, I accepted that decision like a mature adult.

I’ve also indicated that should Blizzard decide to add the non vanilla QOL convenience of guild banks to Classic, I will also accept that decision like a mature adult even though I disagree.

[Starman-zangarmarsh (Starman)]

Was that thread created AFTER Blizzard made their decision that they would be implementing 1.12 AV?

So I guess you don’t care as much as you say you do, or you’d be all vocal in there.

[Fesz-cenarius]

Was that thread created AFTER Blizzard made their decision that they would be implementing 1.12 AV?

So I guess you don’t care as much as you say you do, or you’d be all vocal in there.

I said the decision has already been made and that while I disagree with the decision, I accept it like a mature adult.

[Starman-zangarmarsh (Starman)]

@Fesz-cenarius

I said the decision has already been made and that while I disagree with the decision, I accept it like a mature adult.

Flying in Draenor and Real Names in battle.net say hi.

[Studmuffyn-veknilash (Studmuffyn)]

Using your name like you asked brings up a list of posts