Will Sylvanas return help or hurt the game?

Countless races according to Maiev.

The Night Elves did not wipe the trolls out with that crushing victory, nor was that their goal, so no genocide there. Plus, there are times where the underdog is in the wrong.

1 Like

Is that why most of the world supports palestine? Newsflash. If you are a ruthless jerk and humilate an entire race on purpose people tend to hate you more often. And Azshara and her entire empire deserve all the hate possible.

Truth be told, Azshara wasnā€™t even remotely interested in the trolls. She considered them a nusance that she grew bored of pretty quickly once her empire expanded as far as it did

She had no actual interest in genociding the trolls, because she certaintly had the capabilities and power to do so. Instead she forced the Zandalari to police the other troll tribes and reign them in

Side Note: Seriously though, is it likely that smaller unknown tribes were wiped out? Probably. But we will never know if that was due to kaldorei aggression, they simply starved to death, or fled and were folded into their respective tribes

It doesnā€™t matter what her intentions was. She abused her power to humiliate an entire race of people and steal all their land to build her own empire. She gets the same hate for why Israel is getting hate by attacking targets who arenā€™t aven aligned with the Hamas. Unlimited power makes you an unlimited douchebag by default.

Actually, it does matter. A lot actually. Especially when trying to judge someone

Azshara is a villain who caused damage the same scale as the burning legion so why are you defending her like she is some misunderstand anti hero?

what?? iā€¦ what???

Nobodyā€™s defending her erevien. Just pointing out actual facts about how she felt about the trolls back than.

She did not care about them, in her eyes they were beneath her in every regard

Side Note: Sheā€™s nowhere near the scale of evil that the burning legion was. Thereā€™s a reason sheā€™s a fantastic villain that most of us actually enjoy

Yes she did the best she could to turn them into broken people without purpose. The decline of all troll nations started due to HER reign. That is also a fact. And the Sundering is her direct fault.

This nonsense is why your threads get axed

1 Like

No she didnā€™t erevien. Thereā€™s a reason she GREW BORED of them and forced the Zandalari to police them

She took the troll land and most likley demanded tribute payments during her reign. And then plastered new night elf cities all over her new empire which is why we see their ruins everywhere today still.

I will not ignore troll genocide just because it makes elf fans uncomfortable.

Thatā€™sā€¦.how empire building works Erevien.

Side Note: Wait until you learn that nearly every country in the world has had an empire at one point in history.

Heā€™s referring to you bringing up irl stuff, but as I said earlier itā€™s inevitable.

We need some real comparisons because it seems in a fictional world people seem to not realise how these wars, agressions, land takings etc work until the people sitting behind their monitors see it with their own eyes.

1 Like

Where are the troll city ruins then? They almost controlled just as much land as the night elves did.

If you look at the map of the kaldorei empire, there is a lot of vast open space inbetween the major cities. We donā€™t know if anyone actually lived in those vast untamed areas or not.

There couldā€™ve been smaller unknown tribes. Itā€™s certaintly a possibility

The word genocide only enters the conversation because of narrative bias.

The incident in question is the only time I can think of, (in the lore) when a besieged party is given the opportunity to almost fully evacuate as a matter of strategy. This is confirmed when sheā€™s all ā€œThereā€™s no one left sob sobā€ Thatā€™s genocide because Golden said so, but itā€™s not worse (in terms of brutality and mass murder) than the purge.

2 Likes