I mean, to hypotheticise in a VElf-less world, Blizz has had BElves vs HElves as a thing ever since Wrath. Its why every single request is āWe want WC2 High Elvesā which, coincidentally, is something BElves have moved away from aesthetically
The problem is, well, VElves happened instead and lead to our current mess
Iād prefer storyline consistent stuff over new. VElves were a mistake. I do not want something like VElves ever again.
Give me Arakokra. Give me Jinyu. Give me something that makes sense and has been in the game previously. Do not throw your original character donut steel into the game as a brand new race and pretend I should be happy with it
I believe that a lot of the high elf demand comes from a misguided notion that they will gain back the players that they lost from blood elves being added to the game.
But the truth is, it wonāt. For people to come back to Alliance for a race, youāre gonna have to have blizz give you a truly unique race that a ton of the playerbase likes. The people playing blood elf right now have no reason to go back to the alliance for a race that looks exactly the same.
Why would this be the scenario and not the Nathanos model?
Do you not notice how many (it really only seems to stem from Alliance HE fans and not all of them but enough to be annoying) but how many people still wonāt and canāt get over a WC2 delusion and actively āarenātā happy for Horde having Blood Elves? There is a sentiment I personally have seen from some where despite everything and having this victory for the HE community its still āwell BEās being Horde is still a mistake!ā and its like oh my god can you just enjoy your moment leave Blood Elves alone.
And I think in my opinion thats a lot of it, too many people have coupled the HE request for the Alliance with a bitterness towards Blood Elves, and its not a surprise to me now that Horde and Hordes most popular race with a large fan base of its own isnāt happy.
Also what have Blood Elves received in return? You have people like me who are happy but now I see a disparity, VEās got an entire second visual theme, and BEās got? An eye color? Some jewelry? It doesnāt sit well with me personally.
I said elves. I was talking about both blood elves and void elves, and both genders. I also said compared to other races. The worgen just got different colored eyes and the males got an ear option.
Thatās really not the case. They wanted High Elves. They got Void Elves which did little to nothing to address their request. Now they are getting the skin tones which partially addresses their request. The hair is the last thing left to address the request to a reasonable degree.
Tattoos and scars are generic asks for any race. I donāt feel it fair to lump that in with āthey keep asking for moreā. I donāt see anyone complaining about other races asking for tattoos and scars. Why should Void Elves be held to a different standard? Also players do not have some sort of limit as to how many things they can ask for. The only limits are what the devs are willing and able to give, and when they can give them. Players ask for things, they get them, and then ask for new things. This is not exclusive to those seeking High Elves.
As far as Classes goā¦ unfortunately there are going to be a few outliers asking for Paladins. But unless Blizzard bends their own lore over backwards to allow it, I wouldnāt expect it to ever happen. The same for Druids or Shaman or Demon Hunters. And frankly I donāt think any of those classes are necessary to fulfill the High Elf fantasy. Most Alliance High Elves seem to be Mages, Priests and Hunters if anything.
As to this comment because I see it touted often enough:
The whole āgive an inch, they take a mileā is very appropriate for the High Elf community.
Iāll simply reply with my own retort:
If I ask for 8 inches, but Iāll be satisfied with 6 inches, and you only offer me one inch, Iām going to keep asking for more inches until youāre able to hit my sweet spot.
Uhhhh as a completely like, non-invested person who has never taken part in this debate hereās what I think FWIW:
Blood Elves are High Elves
But, there are still thousands of High Elves loyal to the alliance
Before the addition of allied races, there wasnāt much of a reason to make alliance high elves playable because they were such a small part of the population. basically homeless refugees.
The addition of allied races made it much more reasonable
Void elves on the alliance seem to be essentially these refugees and maybe a few horde defectors
Alleria leads them and she does not look like a tentacle monster
Therefore I think it is completely reasonable for Void Elves to have more traditional styling options, including some blood elf ones.
Also, Void Elf is a dumb name. They should have just called themselves High Elves and allowed them to choose the weird appearances. That would have been pretty metal.
Yea, thatās affected a lot of peopleās perception on high elves as well. The average helfer you see going around is spouting off about Horde Bias TM with all doom and gloom trying to act like the alliance never gets anything. And when we do they try to twist it in a way that makes it a bad thing or compares it to some arbitrary thing the horde has to claim itās not enough.
Not really. Alleria has kept her high elf looks. And she has gone more void than the void elves. She has taken in the essence of a void corrupt naaru.
Also with void elf lore not existent beyond we go find them on this rock on the edge of the void a fair skinned Void elf could just be a void elf that was saved who got there recently. They werenāt there long enough to go blue/purple.
Then why didnāt worgen get as many customizations as their human forms?
Yes, but that doesnāt mean we use it 24/7. Almost everyone who plays a worgen plays it for worgen, not for their human form. Only a Gilneas rper spends all their time in human form.
This is my issue as well and I would say I have seen what I felt was the biggest victory for the HE community and what I wished for them to have happened already which was lore for the wayfarers which the art directorās comments on the options for both sides being for HEās basically can be that lore connection I know people wanted.
Iām very unhappy with what BEās received in comparison, I feel VEās got more meaningful options during core race customizations no less, and the HE community wants to ignore whatās been done in respect to what they already have. To paraphrase a good analogy I saw the other day they want everyone to āignoreā the fact they got 2 slices of pie, and want to focus on only talking about sharing the last piece of pie left out of respect for fairness while completely overlooking the fact they already had two slices.
Iāve also seen a āwe want more Void customizations tooā¦ after more HE onesā Itās like Blizzard gave them the aux cord for one song, and they keep playing their music not giving it back like, chill, I thought it was cute I liked the beat, but were moving on give the aux back.
The people asking for this would have better luck asking for all races to be able to play all classes then trying to ask for void elf pallies, DH, druids, shamans ect ect.