Indeed…the treaty only made sure that the trolls simply gave up, so that the night elves could expand undisturbed.
I am standing by my word.
And I didn’t lie.
YOu lied today many…many…many times…or you have indeed no idea …i post it…many times…
3 Likes
Not once.
It’s even mentioned in Chronicles the Amani attacked the Elves (after they entered Amani territory) because they though they are Night Elves.
IT’S NOT ABOUT THE AMANI! IT’S ABOUT YOUR TESTIMONY ON THE TREATY!
BOAAh, how it upsets me when someone twists the facts then afterwards about what the statements went about. It was all about the content of the contract in our last discussion, I posted every section of it because you said you never argued against it.
Thats…is a lie…you argued against that…today…a few hour ago. Anyone can read it, I’m just posting your statement. I’m not posting anything other than your testimony.
You didn’t know, despite the fact that I posted the source? I just didn’t write it down. I linked it…three times
2 Likes
And? No lie anywhere.
And also:
This treaty no longer gave these indigenous people any rights, the Zandalari not only threw all the tribes under the bus but also made sure that it could happen at all through their influence.
But you brought the treaty up at all, you said they broke the treaty, INFO; they didn’t. The treaty would have given them every right to the land.
Face palm No I never did argue against what he said about the Zandalari. I agreed with him on one thing. That the Zandalari did throw the other tribes under the bus. Those are two different discussions.
Then stop doing it. Most of what you quoted from me above was:
a lie again…she never said such a thing…she said" YOU Zandalari, on my grace, you are allowed to live there…if you upset me…i end you…and all other trolls have no rights…bye 
Oh…and …make shure…this barbaric primitives do not dare to disrupt my plans…otherwise i´ll end you too"
The Zandalari had nothing to say in this treaty. They were allowed to keep their home at Azshara’s mercy,and only the zandalari were allowed.
You should walk away, take a deb breath and come back later.
if you stop to lie…
Grow up really. You can say you disagree (even though keeping piece over the tribes was mentioned their capitols left alone etc).
You can’t say I’m lying because I don’t bow down to you nonsense.
You know, I don’t mind if someone simply doesn’t know, but even if I post it, you can read it, and then still claim the same thing, then it’s a lie, because then you simply know better at that time, but still claim the wrong thing with better knowledge.
This is not nonsense, but simply what happened. Zandalari gave up all claim, to every piece of land, for all troll tribes except their own, to Azshara and their chosen highborne.
1 Like
It’s called interpretation you…
Such things are reason for war all the time in our world. I’s astonishing you don’t now this. You really need to get some air or I don’t know how to help you.
Yes keeping the peace over all the tribes was part of the treaty.
Nop, it wasn´t…only…for Zandalari, you lied again.
I’m not saying it was a good thing for the Highborne to do. I’m saying it was a very bad thing for the Highborne to do. Everyone else is trying to downplay how bad it was, and argue that even if they did the very bad thing, people shouldn’t act like it was a very bad thing and saying it was a very bad thing is “projecting”.
Because whenever anyone asks why the Highborne kept settling the land and killing Amani, it’s always brought up that the Amani struck first, like this is evidence of their unreasonableness and a mitigating factor on the part of the Highborne. They bring up how the Amani should have not left the land as ruins, as if evidence of their unreasonableness that’s a mitigating factor on the part of the Highborne.
Or any other number of explanations about why the Amani genocide at the hands of the Highborne was just not really any kind of tragic thing. I mean definitely not as bad as >insert any quest where tribespeople kill us and we collect their heads for bounty as a matter of fact.<
And I’m projecting? I, and most of the people posting here live in countries that are built on the backs of such genocide. Honestly, it’s kind of in my best interest to defend the historical/contemporary practices to some degree, insulated as I am from many of its worst affects.
If anyone is projecting, it’s people who try to downplay genocide and colonialism when- as a recent expansion so clearly showed- it’s definitely not something most think is okay or something that should be downplayed.
WoW’s not even subtle about the parallels. It’s players who’re making excuses for it.
But not unnerving enough for High Elves to later live among humans in Lordaeron, Dalaran, and other cities in the Tirisfall region later.
Just enough to “force” them into a situation where they simply had no choice but to displace and kill the Amani.
Not Drazar’Alor. Everything South of Stormwind. Everything around the Arathi Highlands. If you’ve ever gotten a “Kill X troll quests” your character was asked to participate in the ongoing genocide of the Trolls, generally for the purposes of protecting settlements from being attacked by Trolls.
The Amani empire wasn’t always so small as it is now and it doesn’t just stay that way due to lack of defense.
5 Likes
Troll somewhere else really. The Zandalari agreed to keep the tribes in check you liar.
Yes, but only the empire of the zandalari was promised to be spared in case of an attack, and to be allowed to keep it. at Azshara’s mercy.
That is not an interpretation, it’s written down, and you agreed to it earlier. So you are lying to AGAIN!
1 Like
I’d say that, except all the playable races have suffering genocide be a big part of their story- and carrying it out in kind. But it’s never really a thing brought up as this terrible and tragic thing when Elves, Dwarves, and Humans do it. Even against other player races. And always downplayed or justified.
4 Likes
That’s the part for the Zandalari. It no where says the tribes have to abandon their land.
That’s the point! The other tribes also did not agree to anything.
You can’t call me a liar for disagreeing with your interpretation.
You can say you think I’m wrong sure. But I’ve even given you my reasoning. That’s a form of trolling to say I mean this and that, when I’ve explained my reasoning here.
That’s no a way to argue.