Longtime blood elf player here. I think many people’s problem with “just go horde” is that the blood elves don’t fit the horde’s aesthetic at all (so much that many horde non-BE players will actually agree). I got sick of being run by orcs and undead, I got sick of my garrison being composed of mud huts, so I got VE (which I don’t even currently play) and my BE characters are effectively retired. I don’t play elves anymore because they don’t make sense to me on Horde and I’ve driven night elves (this character used to be one) into the ground in terms of interest.
I’m happy for the new Worgen models because they’ve always been my favorite race I couldn’t quite stand to look at; Genn has always been my favorite faction leader and I’m glad I can join his clan without looking like poorly designed crap.
I’ll say again, it would not bother me at all if people could work toward changing their faction. That’s a rep grind I’d actually want to do, not just one for a gimmicky AR that will inevitably just become another character I probably won’t even main, so what’s the point.
Taking a character and changing factions (or even better getting a pass from both), even if the reqs were as ridiculous as pathfinder, would be one more useful thing to do in this game, and I’m not a racist so if, say, an orc can prove he isn’t down with Sylvanas’ leadership, say, and would rather help the opposition, I say good on him! And if a human wants to go feral and hang out with the greenskins instead, as long as he can prove his worth and that he believes in honor above all else, good on him as well!
Rigid factions are for RTS’s, not MMO’s. The rigid factioning of this game, were it not so old that it’s become “just the way things are,” and as such so people are okay with it literally by default, was clearly seen to me as a detriment when I came over from EQ in 2005ish. It’s like literally the only backwards step they took.
I thought this game was a brilliant iteration of the massively punishing gameplay of EQ, but the factioning felt like they dumbed something down in the process.
Also if they provided a path to changing factions we’d have at the very least less “faction bias” that so many people love to taught, it would all be whatever you want it to be. MMOs should be all about personal options first and foremost. I for one would love to RP that one race “from the other side” who somehow managed to fit in, the possibilities there are endless! Forcing us to keep our faction no matter what just makes us all look like ideological lunatics.
I see zero value in the faction I play, other than I prefer Alliance architecture to Horde, and that’s a pretty slim reason.