It’s not mind-reading; it’s common sense. Why else would someone be against dungeon finder? I’ve read thousands of posts on the subject and I haven’t seen any reason. Saying ‘community’ is nonsense. Look at TBCC…it’s a catastrophe. The lfg channel is just endless buying and selling spam. A dungeon finder only helps the community. As I said, it has no impact on people who want to ruin dungeons with friends or guildies. All it is is an additional option for people who (for whatever reason) don’t have the friends or guildmates to run dungeons. And even for those people, it’s a useful tool. Your friends aren’t always online. Guildies aren’t always available. Maybe you can’t fill out a full party, but need 1 or 2 more people.
This notion that spamming the lfg channel to group with random strangers is more meaningful than being automatically grouped with random strangers is completely preposterous. The only critique for the system would be that it’s cross-realm. But that’s kind of necessary for dead servers.
If I was Blizzard, it’s very simple what I would do: remove the cross-realm aspect and merge dead realms. Done. That’s all they need to do.