I’ve been going through TBC Classic some to explore Dustwallow Marsh and see what the area was like during the old Vanilla days, and it got me thinking a bit more about the rumors that Ogres were considered as a race for Vanilla back in the day. I wanted to think some more on that line of thinking.
When looking back at Ogres during Vanilla, it is said that Blizzard debated between them and Tauren, the main factor being that they wanted a big race and development time couldn’t lead to them both getting in at launch. Tauren were ultimately chosen in the end, but if they weren’t, I do wonder if Thunder Bluff would still be in the game as a capital city at the time. I assume Tauren would still be part of the Horde as a NPC race, and it’s hard to imagine access to Mulgore being locked until a future expansion happened. Maybe Cataclysm (assuming this timeline has the same expansions albeit with some potential feature differences like playable races) would’ve been the latest we’d see Tauren playable, but that is quite a bit of time having passed for them to not be playable given their importance to the Horde.
If Thunder Bluff were still a capital city, then I wouldn’t really expect the Stonemaul Ogres to have their own capital city. Maybe the Darkspear Trolls would’ve had a capital city that was farther located from Orgrimmar, and the Ogres would be the race that lost their home still to the dragonkin that sent them running in our timeline. Dustwallow Marsh could still be for the most part the same, maybe with an Ogre starting area there still or maybe they’d start with the Orcs, who want to help them get their home back so they don’t take over all the land in Durotar.
Otherwise, we’d see the Stonemaul home become a capital city. A bigger, more grand area in Dustwallow Marsh where they didn’t lose their home, but have to contend both with Theramore and Onyxia’s minions. In a way, it could be fitting since the Horde vs Alliance theme was still a main factor of the game.
I assume that Dustwallow Marsh would be where starting Ogre players would’ve started. Maybe a short distance away from their capital city, starting off in an enclosed area where newbie Ogres go to bash stuff and get ready to be an adventurer. I can only imagine the type of quests there, which could involve Theramore spies in the area among other things.
For the racial leader, I’m sure it would’ve been Mok’Morokk still, who Rexxar put in charge. The question would be whether he would still have been corrupted at some point and replaced with Tharg in the future, or if he would’ve stayed loyal to the Stonemaul Clan…at least for awhile unless they did something with him in a future expansion like with most Horde racial leaders. Maybe he would’ve become a Horde hero and still be the Stonemaul leader during Shadowlands, maybe he would’ve become a raid boss at some point, maybe he would’ve cooked the best darn cookies you could ever find on Azeroth and end the Horde and Alliance war as a result. Who knows? It’s hard to know if Tharg would’ve been a character in this timeline also, especially if Mok’Morokk stayed good.
There are other aspects to consider in such a timeline where we got Ogres instead of Tauren at first, but those are some that stick out in my mind. This isn’t to say I’m complaining that we got Tauren instead, far from it. It’s just something fun to speculate on, and of course Tauren are an important member of the Horde. I can’t imagine a timeline where we didn’t get Tauren at all and we’d have a Tauren megathread on here to try to get them playable.
If I think of anything else to type about regarding if Ogres became playable during Vanilla, I’ll type my thoughts out some more. In the meantime, I’m still hopeful we’re in the timeline where playable Horde Ogres become a reality, of course!
Dream big, Ogre fans!