Sylvanas redemption isn't crazy

I would pay to see that.

:cookie:

4 Likes

Standard, overplayed, and hack.

Doesn’t mean it’s not stupid and undeserved.

Who cares? Just kill her and be done with it.

Gonna set you on the pyre next to her.

Personally I would go with the chain her down in the center of the maw and light her on fire for eternity.

3 Likes

So…more of the same? Or… maybe bits of all of them for all eternity or at least a few thousand years in Revendreth! On Mondays they’ll burn her with Light, on Tuesdays the Ven’thyr will then Blight her (which will hurt all the more for the Light restoring her corporeal sense of pain), then on Wednesdays some of her soul will be drawn out and turned into Maw weapons! rinse and repeat!

1 Like

Blizzards stance is death light vs dark isn’t = good vs bad. They stated they want to expand on the fact that these forces are doing what they are meant to do. We consider them evil they consider us evil.

They have hinted next expansion is going to be light being the enemy.

Jaina has killed people, saurfang has killed people , everyone has killed people.

Killing her or redeeming her is both bad writing, another war chief gone bad vs illidan2.0

Similar to just killing bad guys over and over again

Bwonsamdi is dead and his held hostage on the ‘other side’…

On the other hand, the Dark Lady is not yet dead, and, and not fully alive, i mean she can still go to mortal planes so she his not permanently dead, or something like that… The important thing is that Sylvanas Windrunner have powers, chains and purple arrows!

That’s what should happen to bad guys. They’re bad guys.

Bad according to us. They are just doing what they are designed to do.

Luckily blizzard doesn’t seem to want to kill Sylvannas so I’m pretty happy .

1 Like

I don’t dislike Sylvannas at all. I just think all this Darth Vader crap is super lame.

You get redemption! And you get redemption! And you get redemption! And you get redemption! And you get redemption! And you get redemption! And you get redemption! And you get redemption! And you get redemption!

And none of the people who do bad things get punished for their bad things. Gets old after a bit.

Maybe. Yeah I’d like to see Jaina hung for what she pulled in dalaran

1 Like

That’s nice, not sure what that has to do with genocide or the jailer though.

Genocide and the Jailer are objectively evil. Genocide goes without saying, and the Jailer is not death or even an aspect of death if that’s what you’re trying to imply. He’s the OG prisoner of the Maw. He’s literally the warcraft version of Satan.
Also the art of the shadowlands book calls him an “Evil older than reality itself.”

They need those souls to fix he system.

It’s like an ethical purge like jaina did.

Also writers stance is “morally gry”

Okay yeah, you’re just doing a contrarian thing.

Unless your committing the genocide for a good reason. Maybe a reason we don’t know of yet… :roll_eyes:

2 Likes

I don’t believe the numbers were comparable.

numbers don’t matter it’s the thought that pushed them to do it .

I’ll laugh so hard when all those souls are returned after shadowlands back to the world then all the sylv haters will have to shut up

1 Like

What? That’s some pretty skewed logic.