Wouldn’t all those people still be dead though?
not Really killing 20 ppl needs to punished the same as killing a tree.
Jaina would have still don’t it if there were more people
Well if you look at it from the “first ones” perspective.
Ppl from shadowlands aren’t meant to interfere in mortal life however jailer enlisting sylv and Arthur’s is not right so maybe to set things right
Man, you are a super Sylvanas fan, aren’t you. 
I mean that should have been obvious from the start. You can always tell. They’ll dismiss or downplay what Sylvannas has done while trying to put something someone else has done on the exact same level.
Not really I just don’t like the idea of valuing 100 people over 20.
1 Like
I reviewed this slyvanas redemption ,and come to an conclusion since all her crimes were done after she was transformed into a banshee she can be redempted since she technically died by Arthas hand.
2 Likes
Technically because alliance couldn’t control their dog arthas ,it led to all of this.
1 Like
Who would try to stop him on his march sw was ruined by war with the defies and among ourselves at that time.
Jaina should have, but she’s always been weak
She wasn’t ready at that time and wasn’t powerful enough .She still loved him .Would you do this to your love?
because of her love we now have a tree missing and dealing with the jailer.
Wait what’s did the tree have to do with Jaina?
Arthas made sylvannas. Any thing sylvannas does is arthas’a fault and the people who enabled him.
If you look back at the lore sylvannas jumped of icc to die peacefully but she ended up being tortured in the maw. What exactly did she do to deserve going to the maw at that point. The jailer blackmailed her “either work for me or spend getting tortured for an eternity”
1 Like
She canonically did have people killed in the streets per the Baine scenario and she had people rounded up without care for guilt or innocence by an angry militia while Varian was a hair away from getting Lor’themar to defect.
Also collective punishment over the actions of one person is bad whichever faction this is, which that was in the case of the purge. People need to get over the need to make this world of racewarcraft
How far down that rabbit hole do you want to go?
Sylvanas to Arthas to Ner’zhul to Kil’jadeen to Sargeras to Void…
People have been calling for an unironic Arthas redemption arc and I’m disgusted at both this and the Sylvanas redemption thing.
You can’t really spin the slaughter of those Night Elves on their island as a redeemable act.
No matter what crock you could fathom from the darkest corner of the writing room.
i want her to either die or be in imprisoned forever.
this coming from a horde player
she doesnt deserve a redemption
3 Likes
I would say it was planned that she was taken there by the forsworn ,hela had something to do with this. Since, she may have really should been in Aldenweln or Bastion because of selfless act to save her people.