Because WoW isn’t made for casuals anymore and they don’t appeal to that base. They are catering to the hardcore sweats and have been for quite some time
Vanilla had the honor grind, this was not rating, I have participated in every system since Vanilla.
TBC ARENA seasons 1&2 no rating (highest ever arena participation)
TBC arena season 3 rating added 1850 weapons 2k shoulder) participation dropped a bit
TBC arena season 4 ratings increased, participation drops more.
Wrath season 5 participation drops further because it’s become too exclusive
Seasons 5 wrath to Season 11 Cata arena is kinda struggling to get people interested.
Season 12 MoP, ratings eliminated,
Season 13 MoP players start to participate in arena again with updates to PvP systems; game balance that appears to work
Seasons 14 & 15 MoP participation is nearly % equal to Seasons 1&2 TBC, it really was spectacular.
WoD crashes the arena because RNG LOOT and bad bad bad game design
Legion is a template nightmare and the start of the abject failure mode know as “retail”
SL arena gear upgrades are controlled by rating, participation drops even more to a previously unimaginable low.
There are no weapons from the PvP grind excluding R14 weapons, the PvP grind in Vanilla Classic is not comparable to anything that came after it; it’s not a measure of skill of game play, but a completely different mechanism from start to end.
If you had any idea what you were talking about you wouldn’t even dared include vanilla in this.
Yes WoD had vendors and some cool options, but for all it did well it also had RNG BiS items tied to ashran that you could only get by chain farming ashran.
The items could not be purchased for conquest points, it was a completely horrible system because formerly the options at the vendor weren’t as important due to reforge being the go-around for stat allocation woes; this in addition to gem / enchanting.
reason why they diddnt go back to the old system is probably something to do with the coding not being right and them not wanting to fix it or just sheer idiocy.
If you went and asked the avg player when prepatch was, if there was a paid mount, etc
Basically anything not found directly in game, they wouldn’t even know. Most people don’t go to outside resources, even these forums, because they don’t care.
They play the game the way they want to play it and they don’t really care what other people or even blizzard are doing.
The forums are a minority, blizzard has even stated as such, most of the players just don’t care at all.