That’s my point. 
It’s a grey area so it just depends. 
I swear, Vrak gets quoted in GD more than any other Blizzard CS member. Damn Vrak, you gotta teach everyone your secrets to get so much quote love.
Actually your original point was it’s fine to necro a thread as long as you’re not “bumping” it, which makes no sense.
While I too am one for wishing all threads would lock automatically at 30 days - the necro where you were chastised?
It’s a bigger issue in CS because information changes. Not even taking into consideration whether or not the OP of the thread in question still plays or not - the information gets outdated so very quickly. Try and think of all that has happened in the time between the thread was created and now.
All of the hotfixes, the maintenance, the patches, entire expansions… and that’s not even touching on policy changes and all of that muck. The thread you found there on CS and brought back from the depths of the void? It was created back when Battle for Azeroth was in swing. The character that posted that thread has not even logged into the forums in so long (November 2019) that their character was never level squished.
It’s not the end of the world, but you live and you learn. In CS especially, it’s best to create a new thread if you can’t find anything that is a couple of weeks old or younger. That’s a good rule of thumb to follow. Now General Discussion and the other forums? Other folks will gladly fill you in on their posting etiquette because that, I cannot speak with much knowledge on. ^^
Good luck to you.
1 Like
Bumping it as in just saying “bump”, which would just be spam.
Posting anything in a thread is bumping it. This reply to you is a thread bump.
4 Likes
Again, that makes no sense. The rules don’t say that, it just uses that as an example.
“Don’t necro posts by doing things like ‘bump.’”
That’s it. Time to break out the blue flags 
1 Like
It could be someone was just angry because they had to walk their dog in the rain, the dog was taking too long, and when they got back and saw your note they just flipped out.
But it has to be the dog. My cat says nothing good ever comes from playing with a dog. I don’t know, they seem like fun to me.
Your cat is obviously taking advice from a ferret.
2 Likes
I got a couple of days ban from the forums once for necroing. The forum no-lifes were more active 5 years or so ago.
I searched the forums because i had a question and came upon the same question. I read all the replies and the OP never did get an answer, so i made a comment that i had the same question. The issue was not resolved, and still something i was interested in. The original post was about 9 months old. Instead of replying to the question, there were like 20 replies calling me out for necroing. And i was banned. Those no-lifes that reported me were pathetic. I occasionally see a necro these days, and it might get called out, but not nearly with as much zealot fervor as 5-10 years ago.
In very rare occasions, an old issue is still relevant, and the necro is OK. It also helps if the person resurrecting the threads prefaces with something along the lines of “I understand this is a necro, but it is still relevant.”
However, most of the times, it’s irrelevant; the issue was fixed, the people involved are not playing, there’s a new system in place, the rewards were retired, etc. so, it’s literally a confusing waste of time to read or respond to those threads.
What, exactly, does this mean?
They got suspended for two days for necroing a thread.
My guess this isn’t their first time or their first time trolling.
What does it mean to necro thread?
Most of the time, necros are harmless. The only problematic case I can think of is when the necro is from someone who came back after a long ban to start stuff again.
1 Like
Bumping a thread several months to several years after the last post in thread.
2 Likes
I guess it might notify people as well and it’s weird to get a notification from something you were talking about a long time ago. On this forum it’s pretty easy to get context though you just click the post they were replying to (yours, presumably)
There was a post that had no active chats for 9 months and i commented on it without knowing it’s a no no to comment on inactive threads. The reason for the ban was only because i commented on an inactive thread. My post was not updated or deleted or anything. I didn’t say anything against the rules. I think it was only a one day vacation and not three day, now that i recall. I did once get a three day ban for saying epeen, which is faily common word in the forums, but i guess the way i used the word was too much.
It seems like most necros are someone bumping a thread to say something disparaging about someone in the thread.
3 Likes