With the map as it is now, the opening clash usually takes place at or near Balinda (shgy and/or north field of strife. This zone should be Alliance dominated, after all you have archers covering part of it and your Lts. are there to further damage Horde players. But usually the Alliance is decimated there.
My opinion, it is class ratios. Alliance tend to have too many healers. Yes healing can be a real advantage in BG play, but too many mean you can’t put out the dps you need to take the opposite team down. Your pally count is way too high and very much a disadvantage.
Hahahahaha, feel my unfair auto-attacks! Listen as I pray unfairly to God for a SoC proc! Watch as that shaman purges everything my class does! Oh wait
Horde reach SHB before alliance do and in any case is so far from SHGY it’s not worth defending. Balinda is a joke compared to Galv. IBT does not provide nearly as effective cover as TP. SHGY has two open approaches compared to IBGY which not only has a back exit off so horde can’t get bottle onto the spawn point but forces alliance through some narrow choke points on the way in. And one horde take SHGY they have an awesome choke point to keep alliance from ever getting south again.
The best players on private servers went Alliance because Alliance racials are, for the most part, optimal for PVE performance. And PVE was the focus on the Nostalrius-descended servers: speed runs and the like. PVP was a means to getting the best gear-- not that the high-end players didn’t enjoy PVP, but it wasn’t anywhere near their sole focus.
People keep talking about this cave like it makes some drastic difference when it really doesn’t. Alliance keep bringing this up but have nothing to say when they are able to rush through any lines of defense we have and get to drek within 5 mins of the game starting. We can’t do that as horde. We get nailed to the wall by archers and other npcs, and that isn’t even considering the worlds best choke point on alliance side if y’all actually chose to defend. Move the cave back to orgrimmar so alliance can feel they have a fair advantage for all I care. Even then they’ll find other nonsensical crap to gripe about.
Also if your looking for someone to blame about you losing pug avs you have no one to blame except your fellow alliance players. Meanwhile while your pugging av games the overall majority of alliance are still able to cheat the system and que as raid groups. This leaves you by yourself with the other 14 players on alliance still pugging av