tosses more 
1 Like
Nah i have to agree.
Yo this thread is poppin. I took a whole nap, and y’all are still going.
How can you say a movie is objectively good or bad? To what do you measure it? Give me a cup, any cup at all, if I fill it to the brim with water we can all objectively agree it’s filled with water. How can we do that with movies?
You can’t, movies, video games, t.v shows, art, music, none of that can be objectively good or bad, all feelings about it are subjective 
1 Like
Calling people a child is offensive and not a means of ending an argument.
1 Like
Just let it go dude. He thinks AD&D is a board game. The argument ended 60 posts ago when he said that.
He still doesn’t understand that AD&D is not in fact a board game.
Better leveling experience akin to what an RPG actually is. it isn’t just a system where you get to max power in 6 hours. Encourages exploration as you need to explore much more to gain more levels than any leveling in retail, one or two zones will get you to max in retail. You are actually progressing through a world.
Gold is a resource. It’s not just something used to buy new shiny pet or transmog I want off the AH. It actually has a practical use and most if not all the professions have some use unlike retail. Retail has better combat definitely but the classic versions 100% function more as an RPG then whatever the hell retail is.
1 Like
Get quest. Do quest. Turn in quest. Rinse and Repeat to cap.
Which am I talking about, Retail or Classic ?
You currently cannot do any end game at all without people using their professions to sell you things or you using the professions to make things.
You’ll be thrown out of every group for not having your 2 legendaries without professions.
Okay that’s one profession down, what about the rest. As she said
- Mining
- Blacksmithing
- Skinning
- Leatherworking
- Tailoring
- Inscription
- Enchanting
Are all involved in making legendaries.
I envy you because i wish i have the power to take 2 hour long naps. When that happens it turns into 10 hours. 
As i said, reviews.
If a majority of reviews say it’s positive, then chances are it’s positive.
That doesn’t mean you will like it, it’s just simply saying it’s reviewed well by users and critics.
I would give him more respect if he wasn’t disingenuous to a point where he intentionally misread what i’ve said and told me that i wasn’t a gamer, as well him disingenuously thinking retail and classic are the same games when there’s massive obvious differences between the two to make them different (because if their the same, their wouldn’t be two games then).
Nobody but you only think that. I don’t know why you hang on to this all this time as if it’s a “gotcha” for me, when only you came up with that…
You still don’t get it, do you? AD&D is typically not a video game as you seemingly imply, regardless how many video games it has. The overall point was and still is, you’re comparing something where the rules are just merely a suggestion for your group, vs something that has set in stone systems literally coded in. How you continue to miss that point is just fantasizing because a normal human being would understand this by now.
Don’t rewrite history, Mr. “AD&D is a board game”. You can’t walk back that comment.
Yes, yes it is.
Seriously, how many D&D video games do you need before you accept it ?
Oh look nice Rogue our stalker is back not the Horde they even followed me to another thread.
The exploration is lacking. There is no incentive to explore at max level. And like I said that happens in one or two zones at lowbie to lvl 50 and then you only have the current expansion zones. This leaves like 80% of the world unexplored. With no incentive for people to ever do so. earlier expansions would have you questing all the way from elwynn to the other side of the world in Un’goro Crater. If you think exploration isn’t an important part of an RPG I’ll list a few of the most popular RPGS. The Witcher 3, The Elder Scrolls, Fallout. What do all these things have in common? Exploration.
the thing is that is all they are useful for. and that’s the problem. inscription is entirely useless outside legendaries for example. I’d argue that leveling up a profession all the way to max to only be able to create things you will only ever be able to use one or two of is completely antithetical to an rpg. Options should be abundant.
1 Like
You overreacting to that comment is not my fault.
I don’t care what AD&D is, all i know it’s not a video game. Move on to the real point.
You showing me a list of Dungeons and Dragon spin off games does not convince me it’s not typically a video game. As you said before, it’s a table top game. And people know it better as a table top game then a video game.
Quantity not the point that is relevant, and you’re a fool for thinking it is. Not that you’re a massive fool already for being a liar…
reviews don’t objectively make something good or bad
He’s sadly not going to understand and still use the same “NUH-UH! IT’S THE SAME.” circular sort of logic, because he can’t comprehend even the simplist of things i’ve told him… 
1 Like
If a ton of people hate it, it’s a bad product.
If a ton of people love it, it’s a good product.
If a ton of people are mixed on it, it’s a mixed product.
I enjoy retail. But it’s simply not the ideal RPG experience. The game is entirely different. Which is fine. But I feel calling it a good RPG is disgraceful lol.
Sure, the prevailing opinion of a thing, I use that all the time, it’s not objective.
Sometimes it’s not trustworthy at all, i.e Amazon reviews 