Horde PCs and Moral Responsibility

[Arlessa-earthen-ring (Arlessa)]

Just being undead does not make you one of the Forsaken. That pact only applied to the formerly alive citizens of Lordaeron. Proudmoore was a Kul-Tiran, not a Lordaeronite, nor was he former Scourge.

You say this, and yet the Forsaken who see and respond to what is happening to him are, in the majority, horrified and outraged.

Raising someone and enslaving them is not what the Forsaken are about, it’s just something horrible that Sylvanas did which will come back on her when the Forsaken join the rebellion.

In case anyone has forgotten, The Horde is fighting a war for its very survival. Jaina Proudmoore is one of the biggest threats to that survival. Raising Derek is justified by the fact that his purpose is to take out that threat. He is after all one of the Enemy, and whatever is done to him is justified by the purpose behind it.