You want corroboration?
Read your own posts and for once, think critically.
Too hard?
Holy catfish⌠is this the 4000th argument about the SC?? Geez. One side makes them out to be pure evil⌠and the other ⌠well, pure⌠itâs somewhere in the middle folks. All groups in wow have evil tendencies.
Especially night elves when we murder people for coming in our woods⌠
Elyssaria shakes fist at orcs and forsaken
1 Like
Itâs interesting, because this isnât corroborative at all. 
10/10, exactly the type of non-answer I suspected.
Illegal and immoral are not the same thing.
Too bad in-game evidence has shown otherwise. Evidence you so clearly ignore because you know it kills your flimsy little argument that has no weight at all to begin with. You trying to justify their actions as the laws and traditions of Dalaran is absurd.
Eh, Iâd go with them being a bit further on the scale towards wrong than in the middle. If bliz had written them as hiding the bell with the focusing iris in Dal, and hadnât decided murdery Jaina was cooler than teleport Jaina Iâd say middle is right. But as is, they had a reason to act, but attacked the wrong people.
And dammit, with the way they canât let even a speck of grey in on the alliance story anymore, Iâm holding on to what weâve got
1 Like
So youâre unable to think critically, glad weâre making it clear.
Not that it was a secret.
This is absolutely true.
But between the fact that Blizz clearly doesnât know what to do with them after their introduction as the result of Vereesaâs simply not liking that the Horde was going to help with the war against the Blue Dragonflight, and the players that refuse to accept that awful actions can come from the side they deemed righteous, it can get heated.
2 Likes
Weâre agreed.
Then it shouldnât be too overly difficult to provide a citation which demonstrates as much â Iâm definitely not going to hold my breath. 
Youâve now chimed in four times, in fifteen minutes, with precisely zero to offer any discussion at all.
The law wasnât just being carried out though, it was being abused so they could punish the Sunreavers with cruel acts of torture, and murder. Thatâs why those instances revolving the High elves feeding them to sharks and drowning them in the sewers were included within the story.
Thereâs obviously a discrepancy between the Silver covenant who were just upholding the law, and those like Vareesa who took the opportunity to preform heinous acts to satisfy their anger.
Because it was done under Jainaâs orders, who is admonished by Varian himself when she tells him of what occurred in Dalaran. The game also returns to that purge again and again, reminding the players of the slaughter, even Jaina recounts the tale as one of her sins when Thrall despairs about his bloody past.
The purge was more than following orders, it was a violent, and emotionally driven retaliation. How anyone can see it in any other way is a question for a more temperate mind than my own.
edit
Heck just look at jaina by the end of Mists, twisting her moustache evilly as she compels Varian to âdismantle the Hordeâ - This narrative isnât coy, itâs pretty on-the-nose.
3 Likes
They canât even do the night warrior right⌠like wth?? Tyrande gets all these powers and becomes a worthless plot hole⌠at least could have destroyed an unwitting orc encampment.
3 Likes
Seriously, give the Alliance some teeth (as long as the horde story isnât all âwe deserve thisâ) and let them be antagonists in the Horde story. Seriously, I would have much rather TB went up in Teldrassilâs place (with the caveat that the story treated it in a similar way and didnât make up some BS after the fact to make the Alliance into the Good Guys for doing that) as at least that would give me some incentive to care about the story
1 Like
You donât even want a discussion.
Youâve deemed them righteous. In your mind, theyâre morally pure.
Youâre full of it and nothing will convince you otherwise.
Not even. Jaina said she wanted them out. She simply let it slip when her BFF went full bloodthristy.
2 Likes
Given the night elvesâ win rate against orcs I would have suggested against Tyrande angering them.
Canât have the Human Potential⢠getting overshadowed.
1 Like
No. I refuse to give you a citation for in-game evidence that has been readily available since Mists of Pandaria to the general public. You can keep pretending itâs never existed at all in your own fictional world but here in reality everyone knows and has seen it because it is that common.
Have fun, Flat Earther.
2 Likes
The law is what the Kirin Tor says it is, as far as we can tell.
Thatâs because the Purge was morally repugnant, but thatâs got nothing to do with either a) whether it was legal or b) whether it implies the organizational purpose of the Silver Covenant is to hunt and kill Blood Elves.
The latter of which is Renotarshilâs assertion, which he refuses to corroborate with any evidence despite it apparently being everywhere.
Who, the High Elves?
I donât even think very highly of the High Elves, theyâve basically lived like leeches for decades and make absolutely pitiful decisions as a congregation â theyâre miles from morally pure, and I prefer it that way. But, hey, by all means⌠keep telling me what I believe.
Thatâs not surprising at all.
I donât need to tell you, as I said, youâre the one jumping through flaming hoops trying to soften what they did.
1 Like
We wonât ever have that with Anduin or Graymane for that matter⌠all bark and no bite. They wrote themselves into a corner with King Virtuesignal and the possibilities in the future.
Itâs clear the horde feared her even during the war of thorns. (Blizz made the nightelves incompetent buffoons for that event.)
But we had to find in a book that the night elves swept the orcs out of ashenvale in the aftermath of cata or mop? Either way⌠the alliance player never got to witness that.
1 Like
Iâm not going to go dig up evidence that has been readily available since Mists of Pandaria just for you to flat out ignore it like you do with everything else due to you being upset at constantly being wrong as demonstrated over the past 2 days.
And we should.
Iâm no fan of Night Elves by any means, but between Super Saiyan Deer Man (Malfurion) and Tyrande, they could have wiped a big chunk of the Horde⌠guess Blizz remembered the Horde is a playable faction and had to survive, thatâs why they had an old man with an axe surviving his 1v1âŚ
1 Like