I don’t recall ever having said that. I don’t recall ever having said that if someone feels that another player is trolling, they should not report that player.
That does not mean that the reporting player should have the power to collude with their friends and guild mates to squelch that player for every little slight they think they had to suffer.
I listed four things against the rules.
Yes or no?
Well yes blizzard is very authoritarian, but really you should be mad at the people who abused how lenient they were with enforcement.
[quote="Fesz-cenarius, post:1449, topic:89166"That does not mean that the reporting player should have the power to collude with their friends and guild mates to squelch that player for every little slight they think they had to suffer.
And yet there isnt one case where this has happened
We have been over this, and you know it. You can still report it. You just will not be the enforcer of punishment. I think that makes you upset that you cannot hand out punishment.
Who is “we” and how many of you are actually going to “not tolerate” the auto-squelch by abstaining from Classic? Lots of ultimatums being thrown around these parts lately.
Today i learned that less then 1% of the community (~10~?)not liking something and wanting it muted means the rest of the million don’t like it.
Thanks wow forums where would I be with out you
You are twisting my words and that is not what I said.
He has stated that he wants to be able to punish people for what he thinks is breaking the rules. He wants to be able to do it.
The four points I listed are against the rules.
Yes or no?
And when a GM reviews the reports they can decide if a punishment is necessary.
But the fact remains that the current system allows players to auto-squelch others who haven’t broken any rules. And comparing Current WoW to Classic WoW in that regard continues to be utterly irrelevant.
If you are proposing just going back to the pre right click system you are proposing that people should be able to blatantly break the TOS in chat.
that is not the issue, and if they are against the rule then you can report them, but you cannot be the enforcer. Quit trying to pigeon hole me into saying something.
Do you or do you not think that public chat channels should be consequence free places where anyone can say anything they want or break the tos?
that is not the issue, and if they are against the rule then you can report them, but you cannot be the enforcer. Quit trying to pigeon hole me into saying something.
I refer to your previous quote. You said it and I ask again.
Are the things I listed against the rules.
Yes or no?
If they break the TOS then you can report them, but that is not what we are talking about. You are trying to get me to say something To counter what I am trying to tell you. Its not going to work.
Again, if they are, then you can report them. What does what i think they are or are not have to do with anything.
You might have it backwards. There’s a lot of cases where manadatory minimums, three strikes, no human intervention allowed systems produce some horribly unjust results.
The problem with this system is it’s not a touchy feelly judged system, it is a rigid hard coded fact system. If someone doesn’t like your post it’s guilty.
Again, if they are, then you can report them. What does what i think they are or are not have to do with anything.
There is no IF. They are, which means this
He has stated that he wants to be able to punish people for what he thinks is breaking the rules. He wants to be able to do it.
Is not true.
If you know the answer why are you badgering me then?
And yes, you want to teach people a lesson for breaking the TOS, You want to teach them a lesson. Not let blizzard decide. You want to administer it.
So do you think that the TOS adequately enforced prior to right click reporting?