WW/Ele are S, Enhance is B by your definition. Its main role is to support an S Tier spec. Its very, very good at doing that but there’s a reason it has like 1 great comp.
While I agree with WW and Ele being high A low S. Enh is definitely A tier. It has literally the melee version of combust. Every 1.5 min nuke entire team, every 1min doom winds to do insane burst and then every 3min with doom winds you can global someone.
Its super telegraphed and predictable though, in perfect conditions yeah its disgusting but on its own its a lot more manageable than the pressure from most other melees atm. It needs the support from a melee with more consistent pressure and powerful CC to initiate goes. Aka Warrior (i imagine WW/Enhance could work too, Beastcleave could also potentially be back later if Blizzard fix the pet issues).
I don’t play it, idc about defending it. Just the way i feel playing agains’t it versus arms/ret/ww.
Enhancement Shaman does not belong in the same tier as Disc, Rsham, Spriest, Boomy, or Ele. There are 6…SIX Glad Enh Shams while there are 580 Glad Disc Priests, 419 Spriests, 257 Boomies, 221 Eles, and 189 Rshams.
I understand that. But their go isn’t as much set up as Ele or hunter and definitely not telegraphed any more than just pressing windfury totem and getting doom winds.
While they are squishy for a melee, they do have insane healing potential and function on many comps. Enh/destro, Enh/MM (there’s a 2.8k on ladder), Enh/war, Enh/ret, Enh/WW, Enh/spriest. Turbo is just the easiest thing to play because of how oppressive it is, but Enh is literally an A tier spec because they do not need to leech off an S tier spec to be good. Turbo is just their absolute best comp due to synergy and toolkits.
Rep doesn’t always paint the whole picture. All three specs of shaman are viable, and enhancement is historically the lowest repped spec of shaman, even when viable. Demon hunters, for example, were “low rep” through a lot of legion and BFA, even when the general consensus was that they were OP. Hunter is also generally lower rep, even when good. I agree with enhance being A instead of B because it actually does more in turbo than just support the warrior. I would actually argue that the warrior does more to support the enhance than the other way around in that comp.