No, that doesnât sound like what Iâm trying to do. If you reread what I said above, that percentage imbalance is a symptom of the problem. If the society is just, then any sampling of a group of people will fall roughly down the percentage lines of the population demographic.
The solution isnât to just hire to those percentages though, itâs to fix the broken systems so that the splits happen organically. One of the things that needs fixing is broken hiring and advancement systems. If three equally qualified candidates are up for a job, and the person hiring is a white male, he will more often choose the white male, even if heâs not intending to be malicious. He will generally relate better to and understand that person and think they are a better âfitâ for the company. Thatâs what needs to be stopped.
Sure, because everyone is intelligent and carefully weighs their perspective against their biases. Beautiful fantasy land you have there.
Here in reality, there are people who believe what they are told instead of thinking for themselves. And when they are told that eliminating institutional racism is bad for them and will ruin America, then they oppose it without a first thought. When theyâre told that teaching true history is indoctrinating children to be anti-America, then they will oppose it.
I donât discount why it happens at all. Several times Iâve specified that there are institutional oppressions that need to be corrected. If half the country is female but the tech industry is only a third female then something is wrong, unless you want to argue that women are just inherently not able to handle tech fields.
No, that doesnât mean that you hire a bunch of unqualified women to even out the numbers. First, you eliminate bad hiring and advancement practices that favor men. Second, you shift the culture and education to be more inclusive to women so that those who have the talent and aptitude are able to get the education they need to compete on a level playing field with the men.
The percentage doesnât go from 70/30 to 50/50 overnight, but once youâve corrected the problems, it will generally go toward 50/50 without any external interference like quota hires. Again, unless you donât believe that women are, in general, equally as capable as men.
But until everything is fixed, you need oversight in hiring, advancement, and workplace culture to prevent repeating old mistakes. That is all this is. But people want to turn it into a political football of the âwokeâ left pushing identity politics, instead of just recognizing good people just want to level the playing field and establish a real meritocracy, not one based on being white and male.