This is exactly why most people who did Classic the first time around, have very, very little interest in doing it again. I expect that there would be a lot more people on those servers if it were possible to get the transmogs or other things that we were unable to get the 1st time around.
Of course the caveat to that, is that anyone seeking those ‘prestige items’ should have to put in the same time commitment others did for it to be fair to those who got them originally, much like the limited time nature of the Mage Tower in Legion.
Really that’s what interested me initially about the idea of Classic Servers. The fact that this is exactly what a Classic Pristine server provides for, a place you can do it exactly the same way someone else did it 17 years ago.
If you can achieve X, you should be able to get the same rewards and enjoy it.
The problem here, is this. The Blues and Developers at the time were against allowing people to transfer from Classic to Live; and their justification was that if this was allowed, it would cheapen the achievement of those who had gotten it under the old systems.
Yet now Blizzard is going to allow just that with BC Servers?
Sounds kind of hypocritical.
That is why I say: “Ok. You want Pristine BC Era Servers? Fine with me. But block people from being able to do Classic content on those new BC servers, because as with your original argument it will cheapen the achievement if someone does Naxxramas at Level 70.”
Then we have people like Ziryus who seem to think this is fine. It’s not. He and others can argue about it all they want but it doesn’t change that there “is” a definite double standard.
Thus, seeing such an outcome play out (assuming it does) tells me that it was a good thing that I didn’t waste my time with the classic servers now. I told people this would happen in due time, now it appears that it will.
I just better not hear the same people screaming when Wrath Servers get old and tiresome that they deserve to be able to transfer to retail servers. Because if one group is not allowed to do so, neither should any other collective. I say should not be allowed, but we all know the rules only apply to us “filthy retail players”.
I merely point out the double standard applied, to showcase the hypocrisy of this decision.
Nothing more.