What do I want?
For Mythic + to not be some kiting insanity and go back to how they were in BfA difficulty wise. They’ll still be hard at the higher keys anyway…
For them to not force me down a storyline I don’t find interesting, hold my hand ALL THE TIME, and feels more like a chore than fun honestly. Just allow people to do your storyline in bits and pieces like WoD, and give them more experience for bonus objectives again especially if you’re going to make it a grindy mess.
To redesign underperforming, underplayed specs in the least. Or at least do partial redesigns of various specs like perhaps Survival Hunter. I looked forward to class revamps for years because it kept things fresh. Now we have systems that aren’t exciting, far less interesting than in Legion, and don’t make playing the class any better. I Diablo III at least they give you sets that do different things that open up different playstyles, but even then we’re at the mercy of the Devs creativity. We used to have big talent trees, Glyphs, and class changes. Now we have quick switch minimal talent trees, no glyphs, and barely any class changes.
Make your single player/small group content more rewarding and fun to go back into. Add in more achievments that are fun to do for Torghast and TC, add in special minibosses or bosses in hidden optional rooms that drop transmog, pets, or mounts. Continue iterating on this, because honestly Twisting Corridors was a let down as I thought it was going to be a place to go farm pets, mounts, or whatever for fun and it wasn’t and I could swear Blizzard even said it would be.
Make the Maw a place we go to for other reasons other than 1 rare mount, stygia, and some rep. Add in rare cool bosses that a raid group is needed for that has cool loot. Add in minibosses off the beaten path that are tough as hell and require hidden items to even fight. Add in some puzzles in the world like from Nazjitar, add in random fights like Mechagon, hell anything you know that worked and made people go out for fun. And now that we attack the Maw and the threats are less in 9.1 is the time to do all this.
Add in rewards for Twisting corridors based on the layer completed, and yes I mean gear. Shouldn’t a player that has completed a layer 8, or in the future higher, twisting corridors get a potential gear reward from this that can double as potential transmog? Why not? The downside is unlike raids it could drop a specific model and not give us a token like raids, but is a nice boost for players if they complete it. It doesn’t have to be a Mythic Ilevel weapon if it was a weapon only for example, but something around Heroic ilevel at least for doing that content. And if you do it solo you get a specific achievement and title like Horrific Visions.
Don’t keep tying the good storylines that plug in story holes into the covenants. Put those storys fully into the world from now on. I think you’re doing this anyway in 9.1, but honestly it sucks having to do the covenant storylines and see story that could have been included in the zone.
Do a better job of making your zones feel full of life, consequence, and various interrelated storylines. You did a good job in Drustvar in BfA of making that a creepy and interesting zone with different storys, but even that could have been improved even more. Sometimes it feels as though these zones are just plopped together and have content just thrown into them with not as much love to detail and the rpg aspect as they could have. If anything I’d like to see these zones change as we progress in the shadowlands storyline even if you have to use phasing on a grand scale to do so. I believe you have it in you to tell a truly amazing award winning story but it’s all in how you do it. Ravencrest just wasn’t nearly as good or fun as it could have been for example. The castles looked nice though at least, but the content seemed detached and uninspired. I saw the content and played through it but wasn’t pulled into the story at all really as it felt kinda all over the place. I didn’t read much quest text and most I think don’t really bother as well so perhaps that is partly why.
I could probably go on but those are my rough thoughts on the matter.