What all these people who think ranking up take skill failed to mention is that back then you would fold if you didn’t get first cap or you lost at blacksmith.
No matter what faction you were if you lost those two things you instantly folded so you could get to the next game.
True, and you are correct this was especially the case alliance side with how the AV premades were at the start. In general the higher the rank the more you got on the premades due to the bracket stuff. That often meant stuff like too many rogues and not enough healers as rogues are so good at solo PVP and thus world PVP honor grinding.
I know of at least one alliance on my server who was high ranked and stopped when the AV premades were done as they could not handle how WSG actually involved PVP so they refused to play it. You’d think they could handle WSG after world PVPing but nope…
It was a bit different for horde but the first HWL on my server got there by account sharing with 2 other people - so he was on 24 hours a day and all day was spent AVing and world PVPing. He was known for account sharing not skill. To be fair even in Vanilla this was a common way to rank.
Once WSG and later AB became more of a thing if you could get into a premade that beat other premades you’d do better though. I really enjoyed playing with my horde premades. The competition against similarly skilled teams was quite fun. We’d obviously run into some that were better than us at times as well go against some ally teams (mostly from PVE servers TBH) that would just throw the games. Most days we’d lose like one or two WSG games and the majority were against other premades.
Anyway, my point was not to say that ranking was ever more about skill than time as time was always the biggest factor, but just to say that when you’re farming everyone including other premades it’s much better HPH overall, and also typically if you are absolutely terrible a team will not want you.
Well, I’ve agreed over and over that ranking in Classic is more time than skill. I just also said that if you got on a good premade that could beat other premades it was easier to rank.
I don’t really follow streamers so I don’t know much about Pshero but I can say that on my server getting rank 14 from world PVP alone would have been nearly impossible. AV and world PVP yes, as I said the first HWL on my server account shared. 3 people were playing that character and they were on 24/7 and that’s how he hit 14 first.
If someone is selling carries that necessarily implies that more skill is involved than in vanilla since you don’t need anyone skilled in a premade to rank you just need to throw games vs another premade and then farm pugs.
UPDATE: Last night I indeed found someone in AV advertising a “small premade” discord.
But when I joined there was a female dominating the voice chat talking about her cat. She said her cat goes inside & outside her home too much & it annoyed her how indecisive the cat was.