The problem with Final Fantasy is that most people don’t like it. You have to ask why and really, I think that it’s because it has a very different aesthetic that most people just reject outright except for a very weeb subset of the population.
Let me let you in on a dirty little secret: a game lives and dies by its aesthetic.
It’s the difference between someone who doesn’t look twice at something and someone who invests thousands of hours of their time into something. Good game design? That’s just a bonus—they’ll stay for that.
But if the aesthetic isn’t up to par? Most people won’t make it past the title. Final what? It’s a fact of life not just limited to games.
Listen, I think it’s fantastic that you have a game that has passionate developers and is trying to set the example as it were about what it means to be a good steward. But dare I say that to truly be a leader in this industry—to be the next “WoW"—it must be much more than that.
Let’s go back to 2008 for a second… there’s little me, and I remember I had three MMOs that I really got into at the time. They were: Maplestory, Runescape, and World of Warcraft.
I loved the fact that each of those were so different and unique in their own way. What each of those did, they did exceptionally well. Maplestory was sort of right on the cusp of like everything anime and this cutesy colorful Asian aesthetic. Runescape, as bad as people said its graphics were, we all knew that it was just right, and very much part of the appeal. And WoW, that’s when you were actually born into the epic adventure. I’m abbreviating here but I know firmly the feeling each of these games elicited and the impression it left in my heart.
The problem with Final Fantasy is, I think it’s confused on who or what it really wants to be. I feel like every time the topic of Final Fantasy comes up, its main selling point is how great and kind the developers are.
Here’s my theory about where things are headed. I think people desperately want to love WoW, but it’s a long distance relationship—a distance of about 15 years, give or take.
We see all the things that could be, all the WoW in UE5 videos, all the talk of what other games are doing. Everyone knows how much potential this game is sitting on—if it weren’t so we’d all be gone by now. But here we are because we know in our heart of hearts what this game actually is, how it’s absolutely captured us.
What they want, and have wanted for a very long time, is WoW 2.
But as of now is only a pipe dream.