Yes, I think we can all agree with that, but perhaps this isn’t the appropriate place for feedback and this back and forth about it.
To be clear, other users may flag any post they feel may violate policy, we don’t penalize folks for that, even if they may not be correct in their flagging. The only thing that can come from a false report, other than having a moderator review it, is the post is temporarily hidden.
Otherwise, they wouldn’t necessary get in trouble unless they were abusing the reporting system by using multiple characters/accounts to do so.
I’m going to do a little clean up on aisle 7 to remove much of this back and forth, but may keep the thread closed as the OP does have an appeal in, which is the proper course of action.