They definitely should. In 2004, we didn’t know to stack certain stats the way we do now. We didn’t know to spec certain things we do now. So the result is tank and spank encounters that take literal seconds to defeat.
Everquest Progression had the same issue. You used to stack a raid with mages and swarm a boss with pets. It would be down within seconds. Daybreak adjusted this with Mitigation of the Mighty which adjusted the health and damage reduction of the bosses to last longer, Presence of the Mighty to make their attacks more effective against players so healers were needed, and Mark of the Old Ways to ensure pet swarming was not as effective as using melee characters. They also added new mechanics to previously just tank and spank encounters to further spice it up.
The result was the encounters were now more difficult, and felt more nostalgic. You used your advanced knowledge and the fights still felt as hard as they appeared to be in 1999.
I’d like to see something similar here. The Classic Authentic experience should be as it FELT in 2004. Not as it was. Bugs should be fixed, exploits should be plugged. And encounters should be tuned so that we’re challenged as we were in 2004.
Easy is for retail. Challenges should be for Classic.
Retail is harder than Classic or any expansion since ever was. Unless you do nothing but world quests, which is all the retail haters ever seem to do in retail.
Harder? No. Authentic to the overall Vanilla experience? Yes. What is currently lost, is time which creates a lower effort to reward ratio. The core audience of Classic are the kids of 15 years ago. And this is what we have.
Lol at the people who think the game is face roll now because people magically got better and the previous generation weren’t smart enough to figure it out.
I got Daybreak to retune the raids in Vanilla EQ. They literally took some of my suggestions almost verbatim. I was told it would never be done there too. Seemed likely as it was 7 years after they started Progression. But they finally did it after a few months of me posting about it.