I think that a lot of the angst is misplaced…
Players rightfully distrust Blizzard, their track record over the last 10 years is really bad, and it’s actually justified that the player base has all this distrust.
Some of the private servers have done a lot of good, without them there would be no Classic WoW.
However most of the private servers are far less than honorable them selves… Excluding the so called “piracy” that takes place, they’re one of the least savory or honorable groups of developers and gaming companies out there (if you can call them that).
The amount of woefully dishonest things that they partake in or promote on a per-capita basis is actually kinda depressing.
It’s a situation where the players a stuck… Stuck between their distrust for Blizzard and their loathing of Private server BS.
People just want to play authentic Vanilla WoW again, with out any BS that’s from modern era gaming, at the same time enjoy WoW as it was all those years ago knowing that the game is actually and truly accurate.
This is something that I suspect Acti-Blizz is actually attempting to do faithfully even though many of us distrust them…
I think that there is a group of developers that see where the gaming development culture is right now and know it’s not sustainable, they’re more like us and reject the present way things are done…
This is why I think Classic is going to be a lot closer to actual Vanilla WoW than any one may imagine, and 10X better than any private server…
The things we should be discussing; things like what version of AV and why Sharding is bad… These are all excellent discussions…
But making excuses for why we should just “Take what we’re given”, meh… That’s a bad attitude, I reject that fully.