Just want to point out that secretly asking select community members for help doesn’t count as communication.
As for complaining - reforged has issues, and you of all people should know it. It is as simple as that.
They’ve already improved the graphics on every single patch since beta release… what are you on ?
And what do you mean they don’t have ladder on launch ? There’s matchmaking, of course there’s no ladder ranks in the beta lmao.
Graphics improvements? Yeah right.
And yes, they dont gonna have ladder on launch, we must wait AT LEAST 3 months.
Stop defending this, this is just a scam.
1 Like
oh wait 3 months while we can play the beta, what a bad thing…
You’ve defined it to be secret. I mean, I knew about it. You must want some different form of communication than I do, I suppose.
Gaming doesn’t have to be an escape from reality. It just has to be fun.
For a game that is in pre-alpha state when it must be almost finished? Yeah, 3 months is a lot of time, specially after a year of absolute silence.
1 Like
Launch the game in this state is the same bro.
You can play the beta or play the beta as oficial an waiting for updates, but the second one is a bad thing and destroy the sales, so dont except that
Is much better launch a better game than this or the new people will dont care about this game
It works that way since at latest WotLK, when they integrated some WoW addons into the default UI.
wait how are you accessing the campaign in the beta?
I have never played the culling of strath demo map. I am describing what I saw on Grubby’s stream in 2018.
and that stream had the old no-changes stratholme?
He was playing the Culling of Stratholme Reforged Demo map that was debuted on the day that Warcraft III Reforged was announced.
The point I was making is that on this demo map, there was a Warcraft III Trigger Editor typo that is visally evident. This proves beyond any shadow of a doubt that the Warcraft III engine was the engine used on the stage in 2018.
…
Hence why that demo looks nearly identical to what I downloaded in the Reforged Beta, although a large number of forum users apparently want me to believe otherwise.
This is that the 2019 beta is missing! Quote from other topic!
what typo?
Misuse of global variable when it should have been local. They wanted right click on neutral units to auto attack those units and make them flash yellow, like destructables do.
Units do not offer that functionality, though. I was asked this question when I had no knowledge that Reforged existed, probably in mid 2018, just offering help through Hive Workshop.
Rewatch Grubby’s stream and think about how villagers and houses flash yellow when arthas right clicks them. This is nonstandard for Warcraft III. It requires a custom trigger.
After I offered a JASS solution, we discussed it and I also gave a GUI solution to try to make it easier to use. When I transcribed the JASS to GUI for this purpose, I used a global variable for the “right clicked unit” instead of a local variable. This means that if you right click a second unit while the first one is flashing yellow, the global variable changes to refer to the second unit and the first unit can become stuck yellow and never change back to normal coloration. It is a very basic Warcraft III Trigger GUI mistake to use a global variable together with a wait function. I was not asked for trigger/jass help after this, when I informed them about this bug affecting the demo, and I appreciate why not.
The effect of this mistake is that right clicking villagers on the stage in 2018 to auto attack them, if you click them in sequence fast enough, will cause some villagers to turn permanently yellow. You can find cases of this happening in Grubby’s stream that day.
The Starcraft 2 engine would never have that problem, because its GUI system includes local variables. Anybody who says that the 2018 demo on the stage was the Starcraft 2 engine is verifiably wrong. That is all that I am trying to say.
2 Likes
More quotes from the discussion about what is missing now in this beta 2019, lets hope that things back in final release! 
Watch this video at time 19:25 if you wish to see the truth as I have told it.
Honestly the 2019 beta is just the same 2018 demo, but with more work done and more improvements. It’s getting better and Blizzard is working hard on it.
That happens only in TFT missions, not in ROC. If this was dictated by the engine, then they’d definitely use TFT one.
This happens everytime he attacks something, and even when picks up a treasure chest and marks trees to chop.
And it happens in the beta too.
Right, they stay yellow. Seems more like a bug that doesn’t make them back white, tbh.
And, since you say it’s only on the demo - it indicates that there is something special with the demo
Yes, it is special to that demo. I am saying, I talked to one person who helped make the map, and he made a trigger and I was aware it had a bug, then I found video footage of the bug.
Go find a TFT mission where right clicking a unit (as referred to in the jass typing system, unit child of widget child of agent child of handle) (not a destructable) makes it flash yellow. Then again, I’ve already said too much.
I’ll leave you to think for youself from here. It’s better if I don’t say more. Maybe it’s just yellow magnets, how do they friggin work?
These are not place holder models, and I don’t even get how you can consider something that polished to be a placeholder model. Also in the next paragraph you state you think the models are done. So which is it, do you think it is placeholder models or near completed models. It is the latter btw. Also what is likely holding things back is UI issues which I bet there are plenty of as well as general network performance. The code at this point in beta is likely very locked down with next to no new check ins taking place that are not directly approved from the art director and game director as well as lead engineer approval. First week of December I think is wishful thinking, this release will be either on the last day of the year if not pushed to early January. What do I know, I’ve only been working on AAA games for years.