Looking for Feedback on Campaigns

[RoughRider-11165]

Just wanted to link these reviews as well as provide more links to the other campaigns I’ve created(refer to first post).

Campaign review: Wingman

Campaign review: Timeline

I finished playing Timeline, a custom campaign made by RoughRider in 2022. Here’s a little review. Mission 1 - “Takeover”: A compact, simple map. I was surprised by the number of units and buildings I destroyed (415 kills 107 razings). What’s interesting of this map is that it pushes to the limit the use of space, and the AI doesn’t get stuck. Enemy units can move around the buildings and the cramped terrain, so this map shows a good job testing the functionality of the AI. It was entertaining …

Campaign review: Hoodwink

Hoodwink is a custom campaign created by RoughRider in 2022. Mission 1 - “Disobedience”: During the first attempt I lost too many starting units. With just few Marines I couldn’t defend myself properly, and then I lost Stukov. I created a Command Center in the starting base, so I had two there. I restarted the game and this time I just kept one Command Center in the starting base. It was strange that during this second attempt I got the fog of war of the enemy bases (Share Vision ON/OFF very q…

Campaign review: Kel-Morian Combine

Kel-Morian Combine is a custom campaign created by RoughRider in 2022. Mission 1 - “Hired Hand”: Just like the Umojans in Hoodwink, the Kel-Morians have the right color. I don’t know why Blizzard didn’t use green. When I saw the yellow Terran Factory I was thinking in the same sound file that played when rescuing it. When I rebuilt a Supply Depot in the separate area my SCV got stuck between four Depots, although it seems that there’s a lot of space between the Supply Depots, SCVs can’t move be…

Campaign review: Forsaken

Forsaken is a custom campaign made by RoughRider in 2022. Mission 1 - “Unforeseen Circumstances”: While I was warping my units, I explored the map with Zeratul and killed the red Sunken Colonies. Unfortunately I lost Zeratul once because, while he was off-screen, he got lured to the brown base and died to the three Sunken Colonies surrounding the ramp. The next time I paid more attention to Zeratul. The arrival of air units during my second attempt made things a lot easier, since they were full…

Campaign review: Island Hop

Now it is time to review Island Hop. This campaign was made by RoughRider in 2023. https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1Nhl5OBkQpp0wDMnAd8oVqqGpaRqPDi3t?usp=sharing Mission 1 - “Surf’s Up”: I enjoyed the character interaction in the briefing. As the campaign name indicates, islands will probably be there in all missions. It is an interesting theme for a campaign, and the combination with the tech limitations of the first mission, as it is common in campaigns, is what makes this map original…

Campaign review: Quarrel

This custom campaign was made by RoughRider in 2023. You can get it here: https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/10_lEp3fdnY63a-LGWhMyUU3VTpN9f4pI?usp=sharing Mission 1 - “Trivial Matters”: The mission briefing explains concisely what the campaign is about. I’d say it’s a short story based solely on the fact that the concept of finding Tassadar is pretty straightforward, plus I think those specific events in the vanilla campaign took place in a brief period of time. So I was curious about what…

Campaign review: Unforeseen

This campaign was made by RoughRider in 2023. Get it here: https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1Hu74FHer8GjyUsVFwPWGgRhtGv583teN?usp=sharing Mission 1 - “Road to Ruin”: In a certain way this map resembled a bit the first Protoss mission of The Fall. The amount of starting units in the rescuable base and the number of Gateways allowed me to quickly get close to the unit limit. But I had to restart the mission to eliminate the Zerg base inside the Historic Town, because during my first attemp…

Thanks again, Savora for the feedback and support.