Is Mercy Truly 'No Skill'?

Here, I am going to try to address a simple problem people seem to have. It ties into Mercy but it touches base with every hero in the game. What makes a Hero a No Skill Hero?

With Mercy a lot of people claim she requires little to no skill to master, stating that it isn’t intrinsically hard to just hold Left Click while standing behind your allies. And if you’re playing like that, you’re right. At that point Mercy IS a No Skill Hero. But at the same time, there is also the loss of base knowledge that would essentially make her a little trickier than at first glance. You will notice that at this point the player isn’t incorporating Guardian Angel, Valk, Damage Boost, or her pistol. Rather, focusing on the belief that Mercy is a heal-bot. If you were to just use Mercy’s healing beam, then you won’t be in the fight much and mostly be running away from skirmishes. And when the community scorns anybody that attempts to even pistol whip some Soldier trying to kill them, they will be discouraged to defend themselves, reverting to Hide-and-Seek tactics and calling out to allies to help them.

Playing Mercy changes the way you view this game. The prospect of combat seems to just be a far off dream, being snapped by the reality that you don’t kill, you help. As a Mercy, your options for a normal team fight changes drastically. As a DPS, when confronted by enemies such as Winston, Widow, Mei, or even Brigitte or Ana, your subconscious thought, your instinct, is to fire. Kill and conquer. But as a Mercy, that is entirely flipped. When the time comes, any enemy who can halt your mobility, or keep up with it at least, is a death sentence unless the player whips out her pistol. At which point the option is weighed; Is it better to just die while healing or to stop healing and potentially not only save myself, but gain a benefit in a numbers game? Sometimes quickly whipping around and firing a few times will startle some players. Since when does Mercy fight back? This buys vital time for the Mercy to escape rather than shoulder her way through an enemy. You’re nothing more than target practice for enemy Widows, and a bonus coin for Ulting Soldiers.

The skill that Mercy possesses isn’t something that can be seen in a kill feed or in a PotG. It’s a skill that many FPS players don’t seem to grasp. Evasion, Situational Awareness, High Reflexes, Target Flexibility. Each of these skills have little impact for a normal FPS game, spare the Reflexes and Awareness. Evasion being nearly unique to Mercy alone. While Lucio can harass by booping and wall riding, or Ana can shut down an entire push by Anti-nading, Mercy simply has Guardian Angel and her pistol if things get dicey. The ability to hop through the map isn’t very hard at all, but doing it effectively while keeping your team alive is.

So I ask again, is Mercy truly ‘No Skill’? Or is it just misunderstanding of a different mentality and playing method, seen as lazy and easy. And what classifies a hero as ‘No Skill’ anyhow?

12 Likes

The answer is no, there is no such thing as low skill

I made a post about that like 5 months ago

I still remember that thread

Truly one of the threads i enjoyed.making the most

5 Likes

That is a very well thought out post and I agree with it. Different heroes require different skills. A Junkrat main will not be able to translate their abilities as easily to Widowmaker. The understanding that every hero in the game is difficult in their own sense, disregarding the overall complexity of the situation, is vital to player and skill growth overall.

1 Like

Heroes can be less skillful than others to climb with.

However, that’s mostly due to heroes like Mercy being easy to pick up. That becomes less and less relevant the higher you climb.

1 Like

All hero’s require skill there is definitely a difference between a GM Mercy and a Gold Mercy, although, contradicting myself here, I would say the least skilled hero is Brigitte as her kit is forgiving towards bad positioning. Brigitte does still require skill though, just saying.

1 Like

She’s not no skill, but the same skill required to be successful with her is required by other heroes in addition to mechanical skill. So she’s like objectively lower skill.

6 Likes

I sure as hell can’t play her. Zen, no problem, I got even got rapid discord by accident, but Mercy? Nope, that don’t compute.

1 Like

But say that a player who is highly skilled with Mercy, able to obtain a 55%+ winrate, is still scorned and mocked for playing her? Are the others right in saying the work and effort put into this believed skilless hero still equates to little in the fact the skill gained in this skilless hero is moot?

Nobody actually thinks there are “no skill” heroes, it’s just fun to say because Mercy players are so easy to annoy. Winston players go over this a long time ago.

5 Likes

Why though? What makes her so difficult for you to play personally when the overall consensus is that she’s easy to play?

Ah, brings me back. One time as Winston the enemy Widowmaker started dissing me in chat. I solo ulted her for funnsies and got my first potg as Winston frying her whole team. Suck on W with a side of m1.

4 Likes

Nah Mercy isn’t no skill. Ridiculous argument.

It’s all relative. Pick up and play Mercy gives great return for minimal effort. So does Dva, Moira, Brigitte, Junkrat, etc, etc, etc.

All relative.

Skill definitely involved though.

4 Likes

If you have a 60% winrate on Mercy in Silver, that isn’t impressive. Most people in Silver could do the same thing.

However, having a 60% winrate in Mercy in GM is impressive because most people in GM can’t do that.

What about overall, in the entire career you have in the game, you have an above 50% winrate. That would show a more refined statistic over hundreds, if not thousands, of hours versus a singular season.

No aim? yes.
But aiming is not the only skill.

1 Like

I will eagerly agree to that.

I think she has a very high skill floor. That is to say even while a player can be putting in very little, she can be putting out a lot of value because the floor prevents them from falling any lower. I don’t think it’s that big of a problem though. It’s much worse for heros like Brigitte who had/have obnoxious skill floors and obnoxious winrates across the board in every rank.

I do think there is a lot of micro to learn for Mercy in the sense that you need to be acutely aware of peeling for your other support, enemy sightlines, stuns/displacement abilities, and when to use the pistol. That’s why I don’t think her having a high skill floor compared to say, zen or ana, is that huge of a deal.

I might be using the term skill floor backwards here, but you should be able to understand the point regardless lol

1 Like

If you have a 60% winrate on Mercy in Silver, that isn’t impressive. Most people in Silver could do the same thing.

However, having a 60% winrate in Mercy in GM is impressive because most people in GM can’t do that.

If you play a hero that’s easy to pick up in a rank where people aren’t very good, that isn’t impressive.

Pretty much anyone can climb out of a super low rank playing a hero like Pharah because those players can’t hit her.

The same thing applies to Mercy and all of the other easy heroes.

1 Like

Gosh this is a good reply. Just saying.

Pretty much all of these skills you listed are skills that every single hero needs to know. But beyond the simple game skills, Mercy brings no additional skills that you need to learn to play her effectively.

The game of Overwatch takes some skill, but Mercy as a hero? Very little extra skill needed.

2 Likes