Basically Bogus Bastion Bias šŸ˜¢

Alright, this is getting a little out of handā€¦

Iā€™ve realized especially recently, no one can even talk about the hero, without being met with immediate and extremely harsh responsesā€¦

That, and it would seem that some are under the impression that when facing a Bastion you have some ā€œRightā€ to win against it, because ofā€¦ what exactly?

So iā€™m asking you, in a civil manner, what situation do you think a Bastion should WIN in?

I mean with or even without team play, a good player playing Bastion shows up, and faces off with youā€¦ should they win 50% of the time? 5% of the time?

Make up your minds peopleā€¦ Bastion is a hero too, not just some NPC for you to kick in the corner until youā€™re happy.


8 Likes

Incorrect. He is a gimmick, nothing more. His core design is outdated and needs to be changed before he can be anything other than niche.

15 Likes

bastion wins in my games when someone Reins on a payload and the bastion hops on the payload as well, then the enemy team doesnā€™t switch to Sombra and we get lucky

He needs a helicopter ult. Remove that awful cannon and just let him use his mini gun while moving.

ā€œHiS cOrE dEsIgN iS oUt DaTeDā€

Is an excuse.

And nothing more.
I will not except it any longer as a response.

ā€œWidowā€™s core design is outdated, people donā€™t like dying to snipersā€

Is a flawed point of view, as you can see.

This is a memeā€¦ please stop.

If people donā€™t coordinate to fight coordination, anything could win against them.

This is always true, no matter the hero.

13 Likes

Okay well enjoy your thread and your hero falling into obscurity.

4 Likes

That actually sounds awesome. I approve.

2 Likes

I can think of many situations Bastion ā€œshouldā€ win in. The issue I face is that I have zero power to influence how Blizzard implements this win condition.

I have stated many times that the only observable effect Bastion has is ā€œsurprise we have a Bastion nowā€. This lasts for all of 1 team fight. Unless its the last one, then your team will be able to counter his presence fairly easily.

I feel, my opinion, the forums over the last 6-8 months has become devoid of all intellectual balance discussion. Not to say there hasnā€™t always been an air of bias directed towards specific heroes or roles. There is something wrong with Bastionā€™s design, and it is up to Blizzard to fix it.

All in all, I play tanks for the most part and making Bastion stronger would effect my ability to do my job. But, at the end of the day, it is Bastionā€™s job to make my job harder. Right now he isnā€™t doing his job and I would like to see that changed.

4 Likes

There are many I think Bastion should win in. In terms of maps, I love Bastion, but I donā€™t think using him on control would be best. Look at Torb and Sym. They got the reworks in order for them to be more useful than just defense.

GM players have legitimately complained about Bastion, but fail to realize he is absolutely one of the easy targets to kill in the game. Why? He legit becomes stationary and is super slow.

They should win 50%, same as other heroes, but in a lot of cases requires so much reliability that utilizing him is a chore. (In QPC I make friends help me cause I love Bastion lol, but theyā€™re never obligated to. I will make him work)

Tell that to the Devs. They actively ignore him :cry:

Side note: Chibi-san, I got his golden weapon. I love it :heart:

Right now, thereā€™s no situation where itā€™s really on Bastion to win. That is, itā€™s less about bastion ā€œshouldā€ win, and more about the enemy ā€œshouldā€ lose. The reason is because he doesnā€™t have a way to force the enemy to play into his strengths. You can only position yourself somewhere and hope the enemy does everything wrong. Thereā€™s no position on any map that he canā€™t easily be countered in by simple rotations and even mediocre resource management. Even if you as the team with bastion attempt to take the advantage and take positions from the enemy, it takes so much more coordination that it almost never works reliably. Iā€™d say the only situation where you can really leverage bastionā€™s strengths to create win conditions for your team is when youā€™ve got a symmetra. Even then, thatā€™s relying on a whole lot more teamwork to pull off reliably. Iā€™ve noticed itā€™s often a one-off strategy and then it stops working. (the exception here is lower ranks where itā€™s more likely the enemy wonā€™t know how to outplay you - I canā€™t really speak on that much)

His kit is just bad. It needs changes. I donā€™t know what changes it needs. It could need a whole rework, it could not. All I know is, itā€™s not good. After 4 years (subtract a small amount of time for noobstomping early on, and a small amount of time for the omnic crisis when they buffed his ironclad which was still clearly a mistake given his kit) heā€™s always been this way and I donā€™t see anything changing that.

Maybe one of the hero releases will compliment him in a way that gives him fair and accessible win conditions.

but if they change bastion

weā€™ll have less ways to get away with throwing while still trying :thinking:

The problem iā€™m seeing is a mentality which states ā€œNo matter if the player had the advantage, i should have a major window to completely shut them down, for playing the heroā€

The problem I see is he was designed with the mentality of ā€œall-in on one specific advantageous position, and hope they donā€™t have brains.ā€

If they do have brains, he has almost no chance to make a move in response to that because his kit was balanced so heavily towards that advantage working. So when it works, when people donā€™t know how to deal with it, it works really well. But it falls off very hard and becomes almost unplayable as people get better. :confused:

This is a big big point that i think a lot of players simply donā€™t realizeā€¦ just like a Widow shuts off sightlines, itā€™s Bastionā€™s job to make Tanking and generally being close to him, hard for the enemyā€¦

Right now if you play Tanks, or just rush up close to him, youā€™re much much more rewarded than he is.

The simple way to fix this is to make Sentry strong again, and dangerous enough to actually make it worth while to force him out of it.

Right now you force a Bastion to move byā€¦ being there.
Thatā€™s the issue, and why it ā€œDoesnā€™t workā€ so oftenā€¦ But when it does work, and when he does get kills, itā€™s suddenly labeled as an ā€œIssueā€ That it happened.

i think the view on bastion is that itā€™s a skill check character for the enemy team to bust.
if they can coordinate and kill the enemy bastion, then they win, if they canā€™t they lose.

however if you are able to play bastion without your team needing to put heavy resources into your pick i think he would be seen as a more healthy hero, because it wouldnā€™t be win on the back of bastion or bust.

i think allthough bastion is usually seen as this character that siphons a lot of resources, people donā€™t have to necessarily play him like that for him to be effective, i believe he can still get a lot of value for just being bastion on his own merits, but thatā€™s just not how heā€™s utilized right now.

In all honesty they complain about Bastion being used in team play, without really stating that any hero thatā€™s pocketed with the intention of winning on their back, becomes basically a raid bossā€¦ and hell, Bastion doesnā€™t even work for that anymore.

At all.

So the real question is, why is he not allowed to work at all even on his own?

Because players would complain too much about being killed at all by a Bastion.

The moment Bastion kills a flanking Tracer, that Tracer ends up here on these forums with a negative view of the heroā€¦ and thatā€™s becoming a problem.

Basically to punish bad positioning and weaken barriers. Im fine with Bastion being here

Thatā€™s pretty much the gist of it. I donā€™t understand how they could fix him without significantly rebalancing the power of his kit. Right now heā€™s like nerf gun with legs, or minigun cemented into the ground. Pretty much no inbetween :laughing:

I would like to know the reason Blizzard never did anything with him. There must be people at Blizzard who view him the same. I would find it impossible that they think heā€™s okay right now. Unless they legitimately just intend for him to be a bad character forever, there must be a rational explanation, like a planned hero release that compliments him or somethingā€¦

Maybe heā€™ll be unprecedentedly good on Push maps somehow. Who knows.

2 Likes

I think Bastion should win pretty much the same as any other hero, as close to 50% as possible.

I see Bastion win in games whenever the Bastionā€™s team has more people coordinating and working together then the enemy team.

I find him annoying(ironic, I know), not because heā€™s OP, counters my character of choice, or impossible to deal with; but because as a Sombra main the split second he shows up my game plan has to go from ā€œdoing fun Sombra thingsā€ to ā€œnever let Bastion get setup, and hunt him down until he swapsā€ otherwise heā€™ll just relentlessly melt my trickling teammates.

In my limited experience on him:

  • too team reliant to survive on him, even with self-repair
  • Recon just feels like a means to an end, that end being to relocate & set-up Sentry
  • being unable to self-repair while firing weapons feels really bad, especially in Sentry

Personally, Iā€™d like to see:

  • him able to multi-task repairs & dealing damage simultaneously
  • have a ā€œtag enemyā€ or proximity sensor he can deploy while in Recon (which stands for reconnaissance: the military observation of a region to locate an enemy or ascertain strategic features)ā€¦ or maybe a little Rainbow 6: Siege camera or drone he can deploy while in Recon :man_shrugging:t2:
  • meme or not, putting Tank on ability and making ULT: Heli Mode would be siiick :sunglasses: