I understand that this is probably going to seem a little out of place considering Death Knight is actually in a pretty solid spot in terms of power level in the metagame, but I do have issues with how weak Headless Horseman is.
I’ll be clear that it’s not a BAD card, but when you look at the hero cards we’ve seen across the 10 years of this game, I have to say that Headless Horseman definitely ranks as one of the weaker ones, especially if you’re adjusting for what Hearthstone looks like in 2024. Dealing 3 damage for 2 mana SOUNDS insane, but it’s actually pretty underwhelming, and games can flip in the span of a turn to the point where you can’t rely on an efficient source of damage every turn. Dealing 3 and discovering a card is definitely worth spending 2 mana, but you have to draw the pumpkin, and that’s way easier said than done.
I think the strongest element of Horseman is the battlecry combined with 5 armor, and that’s pretty sad considering it’s basically a combination of Asphyxiate and a 2 (0) mana Warrior card for 1 (3) more mana.
I think my main issue with why I want Horseman to be a better card is that this is the first hero card Death Knight has received in its collection, and it’s kind of lame to have such a mediocre card be the first hero. I love the theme/flavor of the card, and I enjoy the deck it’s in, but the card just feels really underwhelming.