The argument is that if somebody is putting 0 effort in the current expansion yet he is getting carried to get the best Current Mythic raid Xmog/tittle/Mount etc then that’s P2W.
Either you like it or not, he is winning by paying. what did he win? The best looking gear in game/mounts/tittles etc.
Or just win without buying the BoEs? I have bought only a handful of BoEs… all were from Legion and for all I waited out the prices because I just wanted them for transmog. I’ve never bought a BoE for an upgrade. You don’t need them at all to “win”.
An excellent point. No one is going to spend thousands of real life dollars on a single BoE. Like I said above… I won’t even shell out large amounts of fake gold for them.
Since my rig is basically a brick now I can offer my real opinion. Blizzard was caught selling gear for cash years ago. If you believe that blizzard proxies aren’t also actively selling BOE’s in the auction house (and ebay), I’ve got a bridge to sell you here in uh, the middle of the pacific. To look legit, they allow players to farm BOE’s, but certainly the blizzard proxies in most cases undercut them and all but a few lucky or selected players actually benefit for selling BOE sales. If you believe otherwise you are a mark waiting to be exploited, lol.