Great post. Getting destroyed by someone in full 226 who is significantly better than you who’s carrying someone else isn’t fun. I don’t know the solutions here either, but I feel that at least making the best gear obtainable through grinding and not simply rating would at least help. I’m not sure, however.
From what I can tell, this problem really picked up back when they removed you having to be on specific arena teams. But maybe someone with more knowledge will correct me.
So the definition for you of pay to win is using in game currency to get carries, regardless of the source of that in game currency? If that’s your belief, I disagree with it but so long as you’re consistent.
Pay to win doesn’t apply to WoW. Getting the best gear handed to you is like buying a $600 driver. You won’t hit the ball any straighter if you don’t know how to swing it.
I’m looking forward to Wrath classic when the same things come up there because all armor and weapons have rating requirements as well (accessories don’t).
Okay, so if we focus more on PvP, then I can respect and understand that frustration. But I would amend the OP by saying “WoW PvP is P2W” because that’s where is more true.