I started near the release date of vanilla and I think vanilla was the worst version of wow until WoD. Both Cata and MoP were better. And cata wasn’t unanimously hated. It only lost 20% of subs so 80% liked it enough to pay $15 every month for 2 years.
I highly doubt Cata is bad enough to make me not want to play…I think it’s sad that all of the previous content is gone and I can imagine that at least half of that 20% is people who just started WoW not willing to adapt to all the recent changes from the previous versions.
Wrath is clearly my most favorite expac but the guild my toon is in on Grobbulus will move to Cata and we will continue the fight against the other guys
I started in Wrath and I like Cata. Its only weak point is Dragon Soul, which is a sentiment echoed by most people who actually remember the expansion, as Yehmi says
The only people who think Cata was the beginning of the end are Vanilla purists who think being inconvenienced as much as possible is the peak of entertainment, and people who let the (lack of) quality in Dragon Soul + it lasting for over a year taint their memory of the entire expansion