Why Sylvanas deserves Redemption

It’s very strange because otherwise there was one person who led the Horde. But I think the council is a better fit with the Horde than the warchief. Because the Horde had some madmen to lead them.
But personally I would have preferred the warchief.

I think it has more to do with the political bias of “equal representation” done by the writer, not necessarily that we had “madmen” just that the writer turned them into “madmen” and demonized them as a stereotype. They often tend to fit modern stereotypes or historical events in history.

1 Like

That’s why there is no longer a warchief, because the Horde had too many crazy leaders.
The authors just write rubbish :joy:

2 Likes

That are not accurate to the history of the horde and was never perpetuated at any point in the lore prior to “authority.” The writing isn’t consistent. “Hell Scream was a madman who drank demon blood, his son must be the same way reeee”.

Posting in yet another Lilithia Sylvanas thread.

How many posts do I need to get the achievement?

All of them.

Doesn’t Lil make a redemption thread every other week now?

But it’s about the Council of the Horde, that’s why it exists. Because some horde leaders have not behaved well. Garrosh and Sylvanas!

It depends on how many empty spaces you have left on your Lilithia justification Bingo card.

Oh… that’s what that card was… I thought it was a Ouija board.

2 Likes

I dunno, I stopped paying attention to the sylvannas threads

I would have respected this post way more if you had just been honest and said it was because she got some nice thighs that you want her to squeeze you with, but evil Sylvanas might squeeze too hard.

1 Like

Well in comparison to the low effort troll threads we have seen with other… “posters”… at least Lil’s threads appear to be self aware of how bad their justifications are… and fully embrace that self awareness.

1 Like

Maybe they do, but that would require me to read the OP past

Lol. I feel the same way about some of the posters that start out with “I think”
I actually say out loud “No… you don’t and that’s the problem”

She’s too far gone to the point of having become some kind of monster. Even trying to make Anduin an ally testifies to this. Did she really think he would agree to destroy all of reality with her? Mind of a monster who lost touch with reality. Irredeemable.

1 Like

they don’t want her dead

they want her truedeath’d

1 Like

This is WoW writing sir, no bad or preposterous idea is off the table.

1 Like

I call it “The Defias Special” but “Tiffin slayer” is pretty good too! XD

First off, Uther’s soul split was an act of the light, as to quote A’dal “The Light does not abandon it’s champions.” Hence why the soul fragment that went to the afterlife was all golden and glowy. When Frostmourne kills you, it’s supposed to consume your whole soul, all of it, if it split souls we’d be seeing a lot more half souls running around.

Second, there’s no justifying the deaths, suffering, pain, and destruction this weak character has caused. Sylvanas is a villain with a weak motivation acting like she’s the only one to have ever suffered and quite frankly the very idea that she should be forgiven so quickly is sickening. Fel why don’t we just forgive every other genocidal maniac that’s ever lived eh? Let’s redeem Garrosh, Gul’dan, Sargaras, and Kel’thuzad while we’re at it! How about Garithos and Blackhand while we’re at it!

4 Likes