Why do people get mad at Classic Players?

10/28/2018 09:31 PMPosted by Lôrdgrim
For a multitude of reasons:

To be honest, as an avid Classic lover, we're kind of the new vegans. We don't shut up about it. There probably is also a bit of resentment with the state of retail the way it is. Bit of Tribalism. Bit of hopeful schadenfreude as well. Maybe a smidge of fear that it might hasten the downfall of retail.

*shrug*


Veganism is one thing, but bruh, have you heard about CrossFit?!

In the best interest of avoiding Sithdom, and not speaking in absolutes, I think the OP is referring to a particular kind of dismissive attitude by some players. Classically (hah!), this would be like the ill-fated quote from the president of blizz-blizz when he said "You THINK you want Vanilla, but you don't." They're referring to people like my buddy who almost immediately copped out when faced with the difficulty of leveling up a warrior, despite having done it back in the day.

We get it. The game's harder.

I think a lot of this is like a pendulum swing. The present incarnation of WoW celebrates you as an awesome epic hero, gives you all kinds of legendary gear based on RNG and/or little effort, and gives you a limitless supply of faceless "other players" to BG and run dungeons with. You get what you want. You don't have to wait. I know may super pro-classic bros overlook the way in which these systems are good, or why they were developed.

Maybe the current call for Classic is a reaction against Retail, which was a reaction to Vanilla...
1 Like
10/29/2018 10:19 AMPosted by Gellan
Maybe the current call for Classic is a reaction against Retail, which was a reaction to Vanilla...


Vanilla was only around for a couple years, but the moment TBC happened began the push to get vanilla back. The "call for classic" is not even a remotely recent thing. When BFA is gone, do you imagine many will shed tears for it, much less lobby for over a decade to get it back?

Rather than get a community effort to get BFA back on track, they would rather take a shart on another completely different game.
1 Like
It's not so much that people are mad about Classic. These people you talk about have a basic instinct to hate anything that is trending. Doesn't matter what or who it is, if it is getting positive attention then they feel the need to project negative attention in massive droves. I can only guess that they are so upset with their own lives, living jobless in their parents' basement, that they have to do what they can to make everyone else feel their pain and shame.
sexual frustration
10/29/2018 10:19 AMPosted by Gellan
Veganism is one thing, but bruh, have you heard about CrossFit?!
That'd be me scoffing at people who played Vanilla and mentioning that I played Beta. I'm sure you could go deeper with this.
10/29/2018 10:19 AMPosted by Gellan
n the best interest of avoiding Sithdom, and not speaking in absolutes, I think the OP is referring to a particular kind of dismissive attitude by some players. Classically (hah!), this would be like the ill-fated quote from the president of blizz-blizz when he said "You THINK you want Vanilla, but you don't." They're referring to people like my buddy who almost immediately copped out when faced with the difficulty of leveling up a warrior, despite having done it back in the day.
Yes, there are some people who feel that way. To ignore the power of nostalgia is just as ignorant as saying that its only about nostalgia.

That being said, I do believe there is a minor renaissance of underground gaming going on. With the advent of Dark Souls popularity and the slew of games that spawned as inspiration from it, a lot of people are rediscovering the feeling of accomplishment that has given way to pseudo-gambling and catering to immediate desires that a lot of games have fallen into.

But there are going to be players like your friend that have grown used to the current direction and convenience of games, and there's nothing wrong with that, to be honest. He probably wouldn't like Dark Souls either. Or the Megaman X series. Or Ghost and Goblins. Ikaruga. The list goes on.

Classic isn't for him then. If he's happy with whatever he's playing, more power to him. But there is a market for the old-school mentality. Both among the old-farts like myself, and the newer generation, who perhaps just discovered this new (old) take on game design.

All I ask of the ones who try Vanilla and find the taste not for them, to leave the integrity of the game intact. Yeah, there are going to be some changes. But there is a fine line between important and personal. If it isn't a necessary change, don't do it.

I'm not going to come into your RDR2 and ask for them to take fast travel away. So please don't come into Classic demanding QoL changes that muddle the soul of what made the game good.

It is easy to love something because. It is far harder to love something despite.

I love Vanilla despite the flaws.
3 Likes
10/29/2018 05:38 AMPosted by Matcauthon
10/29/2018 04:51 AMPosted by Fallanaa
Because the Classic "community" attack retail players at every turn, in every thread, everywhere.

So, of course, they're going to get mad at you.

When you do nothing but attack someone, you expect them to treat you civilly?

Seriously... Read these forums... It's nothing but "Retail players are babies.", "Retail players fail at life.", "Classic players are gods.", etc...

The Classic community is showing how much garbage they really are, and proving that as a group, players of Retail tend to be better people.

You say the "Classic community" is better? Prove it.

Also, see you in Classic.


you must have not seen how the retail community acted for 10 years towards those who wanted classic.
but hey, i guess its okay to be bitter after enduring only 1/10th of what you dished out.


I remember it clearly. The general consensus was: "Ugh, not this thread again. Give it a rest already, making this threads every week isn't going to give you retro servers". There were some like you say, but they were the minority.
10/28/2018 11:25 PMPosted by Aileya
10/28/2018 09:31 PMPosted by Lôrdgrim
For a multitude of reasons:

To be honest, as an avid Classic lover, we're kind of the new vegans. We don't shut up about it. There probably is also a bit of resentment with the state of retail the way it is. Bit of Tribalism. Bit of hopeful schadenfreude as well. Maybe a smidge of fear that it might hasten the downfall of retail.

*shrug*


This right here. Vanilla is a better game in it's purest form. I strongly believe on two years when vanilla is getting its own custom content it will do what OSRS did and eclipse the retail playerbase


Nah, once the subscription tag gets announced, half the Classic base will disappear. lol
10/28/2018 09:10 PMPosted by Dizanglolx
coz they know the retail wow killer is incoming
and they dread it


Uh, no.

Nobody's going to flock to a game they can't progress in. Not the way you're expecting people to.
1 Like
10/28/2018 09:09 PMPosted by Pipers
Why do people get mad that people are hyped about classic? It really makes no sense to me.


because half of Classic players will play horde, and will gank low levels in stranglethorn vale for no reason, just solely to ruin their gameplay.
10/29/2018 10:22 AMPosted by Thermiss
10/29/2018 10:19 AMPosted by Gellan
Maybe the current call for Classic is a reaction against Retail, which was a reaction to Vanilla...


Vanilla was only around for a couple years, but the moment TBC happened began the push to get vanilla back. The "call for classic" is not even a remotely recent thing. When BFA is gone, do you imagine many will shed tears for it, much less lobby for over a decade to get it back?

Rather than get a community effort to get BFA back on track, they would rather take a shart on another completely different game.


Yeah, and people want to go back to MoP classes the second WoD came out. I've played on emulated servers up until early Legion where I went retail to play with the friends I made on those servers (by paying with in game gold via WoWToken). It wasn't until the past several years (end of Cataclysm early MoP) that the "Vanilla Blizzlike 1.12 progression" was even remotely a "mainstream" complain / request. Just because you put yourself in an echo chamber doesn't mean that 50 billion people want Classic from the second TBC came out.

And the majority of players are trying to get BfA back on track, why do you assume all the current subbed players are going to switch to Classic? You think people want to play a game where they have to deal with your attitude?
10/29/2018 06:54 AMPosted by Fallanaa
10/29/2018 05:38 AMPosted by Matcauthon
you must have not seen how the retail community acted for 10 years towards those who wanted classic.
but hey, i guess its okay to be bitter after enduring only 1/10th of what you dished out.


10/29/2018 05:39 AMPosted by Matcauthon
short term memory from those on the retail side is an interesting thing.
you must have missed all the wall of no (about having no vanilla), you think you do but you don't, and etc that vanilla fans put up with for a decade.
but go ahead and tell us about dissenting opinions.

So, the "Classic community" isn't full of better people after all?

Thank you for finally admitting that fact.

I'm super excited for classic. Even though I was opposed to it for years, not because I didn't like the game, but because I disliked the attitudes of those advocating for it. Always going on about retail sucking, retail players being horrible, etc... (This has gone on from Classic advocates for YEARS.) So, I didn't want Classic.

Now, after having been out of WoW for over a year, having played for 12 years prior... I'm hyped for Classic, and can't wait to play the game I loved for so long.

But, let's not pretend the Classic community is any better than the retail community. It isn't now, and hasn't been for almost a decade.


It's not that the community is better. It's more that the environment better facilitates the community. People are people and will always find ways to be miserable together regardless of venue. Vanilla WoW was good at forcing people to cooperate even if they couldn't stand each other though. It definitely didn't have a 100% success rate, but it did this better than most games do. Lot's of us hope Classic will achieve the same thing.

Make no mistake though, this is still the internet and people are still generally awful to each other lol.
2 Likes
They are JELLO!
Most don't. The classic players are the players who come in desperate and needy making bold claims that simply aren't true.

"It'll have 10 million subscribers!"
"Retails SUCKS!!!!1111 Classic ruuuuuuules!!!!111"
"Classic had so much better story and gameplay then modern wow" (Lol at this one)

Its classic people that "try to hard". Everyone hates people who try to hard. They're annoying. No one hates the guy who says, "I think it'll be fun to revisit classic when it comes out. Anyone want to join me? I'm rolling a hunter and ready complain about having to keep arrows in my bad. =P"

Oh, and "Classic victims", who feel everyone is against them and that they had to fight oh so much to get the game despite the opporession. Yeah, completely bonkers and out of step with reality. Also annoying. =P
2 Likes
10/29/2018 04:34 PMPosted by Lokubi
Most don't. The classic players are the players who come in desperate and needy making bold claims that simply aren't true.

"It'll have 10 million subscribers!"
"Retails SUCKS!!!!1111 Classic ruuuuuuules!!!!111"
"Classic had so much better story and gameplay then modern wow" (Lol at this one)

Its classic people that "try to hard". Everyone hates people who try to hard. They're annoying. No one hates the guy who says, "I think it'll be fun to revisit classic when it comes out. Anyone want to join me? I'm rolling a hunter and ready complain about having to keep arrows in my bad. =P"

Oh, and "Classic victims", who feel everyone is against them and that they had to fight oh so much to get the game despite the opporession. Yeah, completely bonkers and out of step with reality. Also annoying. =P
But the retail does suck! Well at least for me. So i unsubbed.
10/28/2018 09:10 PMPosted by Dizanglolx
coz they know the retail wow killer is incoming
and they dread it


Because of stuff like this getting 23 likes.

(the same applies for people who like classic and are told they're garbage by retail players.)

The two player bases are increasingly split and sniping at each other. Rather than just enjoying playing whatever you want, reading the forums feels like listening to Republicans and Democrats arguing. "My way is right! You suck! You suck more! You're going down!!!" (etc).

And to throw my own cards on the table, I'm hoping it does well enough that some old mechanics affect the direction of wow going forward. I don't want to play an ancient game with old graphics. But I do remember the slow pace fondly and the feeling of accomplishment you got as you geared. Something utterly lost now.
1 Like
10/29/2018 10:22 AMPosted by Thermiss

Rather than get a community effort to get BFA back on track, they would rather take a shart on another completely different game.


Guess all of the ignored beta feedback, constant complaints in GD, CS, and people quitting isn't enough of a community effort for you?

Which I'm going to point out is in stark contrast to the narrative passed around in this forum: Bfa is a Result of blizz listening to whining players.
Blizz always caves to players.....uh huh.

So which is it?
<span class="truncated">...</span>
short term memory from those on the retail side is an interesting thing.
you must have missed all the wall of no (about having no vanilla), you think you do but you don't, and etc that vanilla fans put up with for a decade.
but go ahead and tell us about dissenting opinions.


You assume everyone here who isn't on your side vehemently is against you, again
Do you know the difference between carpet bombing and targeted strikes,
Do you know what Generalizations are.
Do you understand how your ranting could harm/push away people who likely had nothing to do with your stupid ''war'' with GD,but might be otherwise excited to play classic.
I defy you to find any proof that i'm on this ''anti Classic'' side of your ignorant ''us v them'' nonsense troll war.

I suppose not.

obviously not everyone who isn't on our side is against us. then again, you don't see me attacking a person too much either do you? you see me attacking the argument in question. let me ask you this though. how many times in a year can you be expected to counter an argument put forth by someone without getting annoyed with the argument in question? for years we had people telling us that we didn't really want vanilla and didn't know what we were asking for. when we finally got it, they come in here and start recommending changes to a game they didn't want. and yes, some just posted a wall of no or said #no changes, but others actually debated the points.

<span class="truncated">...</span>

you must have not seen how the retail community acted for 10 years towards those who wanted classic.
but hey, i guess its okay to be bitter after enduring only 1/10th of what you dished out.


There's something called being a gracious winner - which many Vanilla pushers are absolutely not being. Just because some people were jerks to you for something, doesn't mean you have to turn around to stoop to their level.

As the person you quoted said - look around these forums; for people claiming how the community was better and tighter in Vanilla, the forums are showing nothing of the sort. They're showing people slamming anyone who disagree with their opinion, they're showing people ranting and raving at Blizzard over any change they feel isn't OK, on and on.

No wonder Blizzard employees don't post on this forum or give little updates on how it's going. People keep asking where they are and why so few updates... If you were working hard on a game, and you visited your forums to see people acting the way the were, would you want to pop in? I wouldn't. I'd be ashamed of them and stay clear.

Vanilla players have had a chance to get a game they wanted - and had a chance to use these forums to pull people in, engage them and to revel in getting something they've wanted for however long. They could be using the forums to try to build guilds, get world firsts done, etc, etc.

Instead they use it to moan about how this pixel is one pixel to the left, and how "retail newb johnny" is a moron because he's OK with the night darkness being 5 lumens brighter, and to continue to feed trolls and engage in petty arguments that ends up in everyone looking like a fool.

Now this isn't how everyone acts - but look around, and you'll see it's the most vocal group here. Those other threads actually trying to pull people in engage just end up getting buried pages back.

Whether or not you agree with change X and believe it is or isn't a big deal isn't the point - the point is that people aren't communicating in a respectful and constructive way. They're coming off a petty and ungrateful


and you know what? most the time when i debate something with someone, i resort to attacking the argument they present. i have been attacked more times myself by people in favor of changes (personal attacks, not my points) then i have the other way around. but hey. i don't see you guys calling them out all the time. no you attack the people of classic who are TIRED of seeing the same threads show up after a year. how many times in the past year has someone came in and asked for transmog, LFD/LFR, or Class Balance changes? How many times have they ridiculed the people who want to just have classic be classic? How many times must we have the same debate before we are fed up with it?

and its funny that you bring up people slamming those with other opinions, because have you been to the general discussion forums? its worse then it is here.

as for you talking about us having a chance to pull in people to classic, its kind of hard when those people want to come in and change classic into something that wasn't classic.

10/29/2018 06:54 AMPosted by Fallanaa
10/29/2018 05:38 AMPosted by Matcauthon
you must have not seen how the retail community acted for 10 years towards those who wanted classic.
but hey, i guess its okay to be bitter after enduring only 1/10th of what you dished out.


10/29/2018 05:39 AMPosted by Matcauthon
short term memory from those on the retail side is an interesting thing.
you must have missed all the wall of no (about having no vanilla), you think you do but you don't, and etc that vanilla fans put up with for a decade.
but go ahead and tell us about dissenting opinions.

So, the "Classic community" isn't full of better people after all?

Thank you for finally admitting that fact.

I'm super excited for classic. Even though I was opposed to it for years, not because I didn't like the game, but because I disliked the attitudes of those advocating for it. Always going on about retail sucking, retail players being horrible, etc... (This has gone on from Classic advocates for YEARS.) So, I didn't want Classic.

Now, after having been out of WoW for over a year, having played for 12 years prior... I'm hyped for Classic, and can't wait to play the game I loved for so long.

But, let's not pretend the Classic community is any better than the retail community. It isn't now, and hasn't been for almost a decade.


that's funny because we literally have people in this very forum who spent time campaigning against vanilla even existing, and do you know what they are doing now? ridiculing the people who want to keep classic as it was, and campaigning to change classic into something it wasn't. but hey. WERE THE BAD PEOPLE FOR WANTING TO KEEP THE GAME THE WAY IT WAS.

what is so wrong with wanting to keep the game the way it was?
what is so wrong with finally getting the game we want, and defending it against people who clearly don't want that game?

You guys sit here and say we are the bad ones for defending a game we want, but you say NOTHING about those who come here and try to change the game to something else.

Hypocrites.

The problem i have with those wanting changes is they keep bringing up the same debate again and again despite those debates already being had. how many times do we have to explain an answer to them? how long are we supposed to have the same debate without getting annoyed?

you want to know why people have resorted to just saying "no changes" and posting "Wall of No"?

how do you respond when yet another door to door marketer/religious person/politician supporter/etc comes to your house?
the first few times you might be polite and hear them out.
eventually you get to the point where you just cut the bull and tell them you aren't interested.

Fact is we are well past that point. it took us a decade of dealing with people insulting us, with posting wall of no to vanilla requests, etc.

we finally got it and what do those same people do? they try to take what we finally got and make it into something they want. how is that even remotely fair?
3 Likes
My main problem with the Classic only crowd is they think every single thing will ruin the game.
1 Like
10/29/2018 04:34 PMPosted by Lokubi
Most don't. The classic players are the players who come in desperate and needy making bold claims that simply aren't true.

"It'll have 10 million subscribers!"
"Retails SUCKS!!!!1111 Classic ruuuuuuules!!!!111"
"Classic had so much better story and gameplay then modern wow" (Lol at this one)

Its classic people that "try to hard". Everyone hates people who try to hard. They're annoying. No one hates the guy who says, "I think it'll be fun to revisit classic when it comes out. Anyone want to join me? I'm rolling a hunter and ready complain about having to keep arrows in my bad. =P"

Oh, and "Classic victims", who feel everyone is against them and that they had to fight oh so much to get the game despite the opporession. Yeah, completely bonkers and out of step with reality. Also annoying. =P


Mmmmm I love posts like this because it illustrates exactly what the OP is talking about. So why are these guys so mad? They don't want us to have fun and they don't want their version of the game to become like vanilla WoW.

They (retailers) can strawman all day and talk about how the WoW classic fans are hating on them but at the end of the day we can pull up some old forum posts and show exactly how it was, or better yet nab something recent off GD. You wanna play WoW Classic? Great! But we don't want your "changes", esp when you don't even care about the project and are just looking to sabotage it and troll these forums. Authentic vanilla WoW experience only.
3 Likes
10/29/2018 05:54 PMPosted by Tyrilina
My main problem with the Classic only crowd is they think every single thing will ruin the game.

Some minor non gameplay affecting changes can have merit but most stuff does not deserve to be discussed.
1 Like