I know, but even your lead post was aggressive.
As far as what they would and wouldn’t have done, that’s really up for debate. As my thread stated, Genn’s dialogue is much different from the alliance perspective. He basically begs Rastakhan to surrender. On the horde side, Genn basically demands that we be allowed to abduct rasta’s daughter, and calls him a beast. That’s… a lot different.
Something is up with the dialogue. Check out the thread I created about it. It seems like blizzard went with the telephone game when they had your NPC recount the events of what happened to you. Its almost like they were trying to get this reaction out of horde members.