The Brewfest Ram or Warlord’s Deathwheel.
Any of the 2006/7 achievement pets and tabards
I’ve got the Competitor’s Tabard from the 2008 Olympics promotion. Still have a couple Argent Dawn commissions kicking around in banks.
I have A Treatise On Military Ranks.
It’s the book you used to be able to buy from the PvP vendor in vanilla that lists the PvP ranks for Alliance and Horde.
You can still read an object version of it in the Champion’s Hall, but as far as I know the item version has not been purchasable since vanilla.
Got my black harvest title on my warlock.
I also got the Thundering Onyx Cloud Serpent on my first try back in the day. The one that drops from that rare on the timeless isle
I also got the red AQ mount, which i am given to understand was the rare one, on my first try.
I’ve got a Haunted Memento in my bags somewhere. It was from the WotLK pre-patch event. I think I see em on the AH for 400k-1M+ from time to time. Theres not many of these around.
eye of shadow
Easily my “Tabard of the Protector” (it looks identical to Argent Dawn tabard), it was only available for a week during TBC launch.
Not many people have it today. Especially that are still playing.
Probably rarer than Gladiator mounts.
Aside from that, I’ve got the original, non-epic Brewfest ram, which you could only get on the very first Brewfest in 2007.
And then some random Craftman’s Writs and other random Vanilla rep items that are now defunct. (And an original lvl 60 Onyxia’s Head, lvl 60 Heart of Hakkar, etc, before the Cata reworks.)
My old main is basically a Vanilla time capsule.
I’ve got a lot of old stuff.
prolly the halloween horse lol.
I think it’s the pink rocket mount
The Blumb Family fishing pole…removed from game back in Cata due to the area being destroyed…
Damn, reading this thread I see a bunch of things that I have but most of them are only rare just because they are old and haven’t been in the game for 10-15+ years…
My vanquisher title.
Hmm original CE pets. I also have a Voodoo Doll on the AH.
I would say my Meat Wagon mount. No getting that anymore.
I suppose my Mage Tower appearances.
Every single class. Every single spec. Every single one.
I haven’t unlocked all the tints because that would require ~120 RBG wins and I despise PvP.
lmao.
Swift Zulian Tiger
Couple of items. I have 2 pairs of Ruby Shades I’m hoping to sell someday, and still have the Zelda Sword stashed in my void storage.
I also kept a couple of items from vanilla that I was too stubborn to throw away, so they remain forever stored in the void.
I have a 17lb Catfish I caught in Stormwind around 2007 in the bank
Necreotic runes, hasn’t been available in game since 2008 during events leading to WotLK expansion.