patch 3.3.0 came out december 9th 2009 which on the graph would be Q4 09.
If you look before Q4 2009 and Q4 2010 (Cata release). The most amount of subs that were gained in this time is somewhere between 500k to 1million.
Now look at ALL THE GROWTH that happened before wow peaked in 3.3.0 and RDF was introduced…
that’s a total of 11-11.5 MILLION players that decided to play the game REGARDLESS if RDF was even in the game or not.
The people quitting after cata doesn’t even matter in this context because wow was doing JUST FINE without it.
If you think NOT having RDF in the game is going to ruin classic than either vote with your wallet and unsub or just suck it up and keep playing like the rest of us when blizz makes a decision that we don’t like.
Heck if RDF was in from the beginning maybe we would have seen an even higher peak. We have no idea how many people quit the game because they couldn’t find groups.
It did grow, you can see it in your own chart that you linked. The only thing you’re proving is that you’re an idiot who doesn’t know how to read graphs.
The introduction of rdf was followed by declining subscription numbers. This is absolutely true. You can claim its just correlation not causation but it is pure misinformation to claim rdf made wow more popular. It clearly did not.
So we have all 4 quarters in '08 where it rises rather slowly but creeps up to about 11-11.5 million. Then the graph jumps an ENTIRE YEAR during which time it shows a loss. Then it jumps AGAIN to Q3 '10 which was shortly before Cata launch (which is typically the time where people start coming back to the game to “catch up” before the next launch) and it suddenly jumps about 500K subs. LITERAL MONTHS BEFORE THE NEW LAUNCH.
RDF didn’t cause that. Cata’s imminent launch caused that jump.
This graph shows exactly what we’ve been saying all along: RDF had no net effect on drawing people to the game and it did, in fact, LOSE subs after it was implemented.
You’re welcome for the “Graph reading 101” lesson.
People didn’t like how the world was destroyed in Cata and healers were nerfed making content harder. RDF didn’t cause sub losses.
People complained about the heroics being too hard and it was 100% caused by the nerf on healers. Even with this difficulty I still chain ran heroics daily and never had problems because I could carry as a healer. The complaints I heard at the time were couldn’t kill boss healer went OOM halfway through.