That’s a valid opinion, no question.
But take that mage Virtne, pardon my spelling if its wrong. He was a great pvp’r in vanilla. But what if he had never made a video, and stopped playing when BC came out. He is no longer a great pvp’r because the only people that knew how nasty he was are the people he rolled? And I’m sure most people don’t brag about being 1v3’d.
I guess my opinion differs because I consider a great pvp’r to be someone who is extremely good at pvp.