In PVE if you only do M+ 5s then you get the gear from them and that’s your ceiling.
The point OP is trying to make is that in random BGs there IS no ceiling. You cap at 200 but can easily face a 5-person premade inside a 10-man bg that’s full duelist, all of who have 10k more health than you.
I feel that. It sucks.
As the season goes on those people’s gear will increase as the conquest cap increases (if they’re not full already from winning the vault lotto), but the random BG player will still be ~200.
Their ceiling keeps getting taller.
There are two easy solutions to this:
1.) WOD-style PVP gear. It’s easy to obtain, decent iLVL in PVE, then increases to a cap in PVP.
You would have honor gear and conquest gear and…that’s it.
For example, it would work like current 197 honor gear scales up to 213 in PVP, while conquest gear would increase to 209 in PVE (instead of 200) and would scale up to 223 in PVP.
The cost and rate of acquisition of conquest gear would need to be adjusted slightly.
This means we get rid of M+/PVE people using PVP to gear up (most don’t want to be there anyway), and it means that PVP goes back to being about skill and not buying carries in RBGs.
If you get 1800 in rated pvp you would get 213 ilvl PVE gear, scaling to 227. This is in addition to the cosmetic gear upgrades.
PVP ilvl is capped at 227 for all players, regardless of situation.
This means a person only doing randoms can ALWAYS compete against ALL other players. People who do rated will just have a slight advantage through capping easier and getting vault rewards.
There is no reason to not level the playing field in PVP, where it should be about skill.
There is no reason a fresh player getting into arena should be fighting against duelist and combatant players at 1300 in 2s and 3s who have 5-10k more health than them.
If the other players are more skilled, or have a better comp, they’ll win. Plain and simple.
2.) The second option is solo queue for rated PVP. If Blizz allows it in Overwatch, they should see the reason it should exist in WoW.
Let players like OP queue up for a rated BG or arena, let them have their own MMR that matches them with and against similar players, and let them increase their own rank slowly but surely.
– Both options are viable and would work to appease a great many people.
I am 1800 in RBGs on a few characters, simply because I like random BGs, but can’t stand getting out-geared by people and losing to damage I just can’t live when there is a potential 20-25 ilvl difference between me and them.
The climb to 1800 (three times) was painful. Soooo many sweaty people screaming on discord.
The only thing that made it tolerable was doing it with a small group of RL friends, but I can’t imagine doing it solo.