Why do you think this statement means anything? Humans are H. Sapiens even though we call ourselves many different things depending on the context. Youâre just stubbornly clinging to it because you think it lets you ignore a point that does not involve what the characters say about themselves.
And it applies in this situation because the game director outright said theyâre the same thing, among other things.
If J.K. Rowling did an interview tomorrow and stated that Hogwarts was located in Narnia, that doesnât make it an objective, in-universe truth â because the previous publication(s) state differently, and the previous publication(s) are the primary source.
If she wants to order a reprinting of her series and make it blatantly clear that Hogwarts is in Narnia, that is her prerogative â but until then, the primary source is the primary source.
As it relates to World of Warcraft, in-universe, not a single BE or VE has ever referred to their broader ethnicity as âHigh Elfâ; whereas a plethora have referred to themselves as âchildren of Quelâthalasâ or âsons/daughters of Quelâthalasâ.
If Blizzard wants to make it clear in 8.3 that all BEâs and VEâs refer to their broader ethnicity as âHigh Elfâ, that is their prerogative â but until then, the primary source is the primary source.
YesâŠyes it does, because she is god of the thing.
Youâre trying really hard to sound intelligent and it is having the opposite effect. A primary source is anything DIRECTLY connected.
Authors of the literature are the primary source because it is from them that th information stems.
Well, as is evident by their preferred terminology, we can be assured that at the very least the folks who actually write the in-game text (i.e. dialogue boxes, quest text, broadcast text, etc.) are of the opinion that BEâs and VEâs donât refer to their broader ethnicity as âHigh Elfâ â because theyâve had 15+ years to write-in even a single example of this occurring, and theyâve refrained from doing so.
You are, by all means, entitled to stand by the expressed opinions of a single employee â whose time at Blizzard has primarily focused on raid design, and who blunders his way through any discussion of lore.
I, however, choose to stand by the opinions expressed by dozens of employees through their work â whose time at Blizzard has primarily focused on narrative and story development, and who know the inâs and outâs of the setting better than anybody.
You do you, but donât be surprised when I continue to scrutinize silly comments like, âBlood Elves are High Elvesâ.
None of this matters. At all. This is an argument about nothing, to go in a circle about nothing.
It doesnât matter what video game characters refer to themselves. Refer to my Harry Potter posts earlier.
Does he help design the game? Yes.
Do you help design the game? No.
His word > yours.
It doesnât matter that J.K. Rowling once blundered an interview, she is still god of Harry Potter and her word > yours.
Do not be surprised when no one cares or ignores you when its a stupid thing to scrutinize.
Its like earlier, when Guzzle said devs are a primary source.
Your response?
âWell a primary source isâŠâ
Which didnât even matter, and what was worse, was that you were wrong about it and then tried to defend it by saying âwell it doesnât matter what the creator of the literature says.â which was preposterous.
Less trying to sound intelligent, more saying intelligent things.
Yeah, but I canât think of a situation outside of arguing with people in High Elf threads where Iâve ever needed to not be specific about elves⊠and itâs a fabricated experience anyways because it only seems to arise when people are being obtuse.
Like, the only scenario where youâd ever need to maybe talk about the Elves collectively is in Suramar. But we donât.
But beyond that, the nomenclature for it is set for us anyways because theyâre a fantasy trope. We know we call them, âElves.â because weâve called them Elves since 1954.
Original Warcraft Encyclopedia:
Kalâdorei = children of the stars - Can also be interpreted as âpeople of the starsâ. Typically used to refer to night elves.