Only agreeing really cause people also think Thrall cheated cause of the movie and I hate it. If the movie didn’t exist or used lore-rules of mak’gora, I wonder how people would have reacted to Thrall, my guess probably the same thought, insulting Thrall for not being able to challenge Garrosh 1v1 weapons only.
She didn’t deserve his loyalty at that point, for the same reason she betrayed her own warchief Garrosh.
The Alliance characters tend to go neutral a lot (we got a few back), and tend to bow to the High King despite the entire point of the Alliance.
Sorry,she did cheated ,she has no honor by using magic.The same way thrall lost his abilities to use magic because it wasn’t honorable. Only difference was Thrall payed for it Slyvanas didn’t.
I mean I don’t care even if she did. She’s bada** either way. For the Dark Lady
I mean he was kinda busy being cooked by lightning to get the words "You cheated!’ out of his mouth
Thrall didn’t lose his access to the elements due to using magic during the Mok’gora. The elements didn’t care he used magic.
He was plagued with doubt and guilt following the death of Garrosh, and his poor mental health was what was limiting him.
1 Like
He literally says “I challenge Mak’gora” in the cinematic. LOL
so? It wasn’t. There was no ritaul, oiling bodies and stiff
This I really doubts because Gul’dan wanted the same and elements turned away ,was he doubtful? No,they know when you are not trustworthy to use it.
Watch your clever mouth, Witch!
That’s not what he said. 
My wiccan friends disapprove of the edit. 
1 Like
You can’t compare Gul’dan to Thrall. Their motivations and characterisations are completely different.
Furthermore, It’s unclear if the Legion had something to do with the elements rejecting Gul’dan, considering how quickly KJ was there to offer Gul’daddy some rebound power.
Thrall had previously used Magic against Garrosh in an earlier Mok’gora. Nothing happened. The elements were chill with it.
Magic = Cheating is movie only canon.
Very well,we’re done. I grow tired of an opinion being argued about. Good day.
What are you even making up now? None of that has to happen. Learn the lore, genius. LOL
Sylvanas cheated, just like Thrall did.
/comeatme
At the same time there are no rules and dozens of rules, becaue blizz lore has no consistency as usual
The rules of a Mak’gora seem to be different between each Mak’gora since they are chosen and set by the participants themselves. Generally, there are thus no specific rules. There are only two consistent themes in all Mak’gora: once dropped, a weapon cannot be retrieved by either opponent and that the pair must fight to the death or until submission. Magic, for example, has never been stated to be forbidden, and has, in fact, been used in multiple Mak’gora duels and thus seems to be permitted. Similarly, many Mak’gora duels have involved both fighters wearing body armor as well, but it can also be forbidden when explicitly required.
For example, the rules chosen for the Mak’gora between Garrosh and Cairne were:
One weapon was allowed.
A blessing of this weapon by a shaman of their choosing was permitted.
Both body armor and clothing were forbidden, only a loincloth was allowed.
Each participant had to have at least one witness.
The combat was to the death.[10]
The rules chosen for the Mak’gora between Shagara and Ashra were:One weapon was allowed.
Body armor was forbidden, but not clothing.
The combat was to the death.[6]
In many instances of Mak’gora, no rules whatsoever are defined beforehand. For instance in both the first and the second Mak’gora between Thrall and Garrosh, the Mak’gora between Saurfang and Malfurion, or the Mak’gora between Saurfang and Sylvanas.
1 Like
Thanks for proving you’re making crap up and you were wrong in the first place. Good job, bro. I’m proud of you.
That’s your opinion. We’re still gonna smack your shrieking waifu around like a ping pong ball/tennis ball in the end. I’ll be among thew first in line to sell her undies to her “loyalists” for maximumer profit!
And if that’s a problem with you, then I suggest you remember Rule of Acquisition number 21.
Nope that was not because of the movie. Under the old rules, you could have one weapon, one enchant and no armor. The fight was too the death.
Thrall changed the rules so it was no longer mandatory too the death.
Thrall did cheat when fighting Garrosh. That is why the elements abandoned Thrall.
Also Garrosh cheated when he used an ax coated with poison.
Saurfang also cheated when he used a weapon that split into two weapons.
Saurfang cheated a second time. When he dropped to knee pretending to surrender. Very dishonorable.