Send her into the Maw (not consigned to the Maw) to rescue souls in the following order:
- All Night Elves First
- The Rest of the Alliance
- The Various Neutrals
- Gnolls, Kobolds, Centaurs, and Quillboar
- Murlocs
- Anyone else omitted from this list
- Saurfang
- The General Horde
- The Forsaken
- Her fallen Dark Rangers
- Both of Nathanos’ dogs
- Then and only then Nathanos
The more she presumably cares about them, the lower on the list they go.